Wildlife Politics under Destructive Trump Administration

Energy Dominance Rules the Day in Senate Committee--conservation be damned! Murkowski staff names petroleum engineer & advisor to Sen. Barrasso as new staff for Senate Energy & Natural Resources Committee.  With Murkowski, chief instigator of drilling in Arctic in charge & top Dem. Sen. Manchin, coal & pipeline enthusiast in charge, we can be sure that conservation interests will never threaten priorities for energy dominance. See https://www.eenews.net/eedaily/2019/01/18/stories/1060117853

Hunters & Energy Still Rule in House despite midterms: Anyone hoping that Dems takeover of House would affect wildlife conservation policy has got to be dismayed. Dems proposed funding for Interior would prohibit regulation of lead bullets-tackle, listing of sage grouse, & allow agriculture to pollute water even as hunters nos. dwindle as does $ from excise tax on ammunition.  This show how changing demographics & public opinion don’t matter—anti-conservation forces still in control & may well be for decades despite their disappearance as significant percent of population or economy.  See https://www.eenews.net/eedaily/2019/01/18/stories/1060117881

Hmmh, big game hunters versus oil industry.  Big Dilemma for Interior and Wyoming citizens. This would have been an excruciating decision for Zinke who liked big game (i.e., on his walls) but for Bernhardt, the oil company, lackey this is an easy choice! At least Zinke wanted at some point to be like Teddy R.--Bernhardt no way See High Country News, https://www.hcn.org/articles/wildlife-oil-and-gas-threaten-wyomings-ungulates

Interior can’t fund parks upkeep & maintenance under shutdown but calling in employees to help drilling continent shelf during shutdown. Zinke’s gone but Bernhardt worse than ever! Billions for Energy, Crap for conservation! See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2019/01/16/stories/1060116249

Trump-Bernhardt: Keep Parks Open-user fees supposed to be for capital improvement projects, instead used to illegally keep parks open to support Trump shutdown. Neither Trump nor Bernhardt, both lackeys of the energy industry, care one damn about parks but they know public will not tolerate their shutdown—the public cares far more about parks-monuments than “oil dominance.” So they are keeping them open albeit without needed staff.  In short, hypocrites & phonies once again & forever. See https://www.eenews.net/eedaily/2019/01/16/stories/1060115369

Even Republican Governors reject Bernhardt-Zinke-Trump kowtowing to Energy Industry’s destruction of public lands. The midterm elections show that a dominant majority favor public lands & Bernhardt-Zinke-Trump effort to bow down to energy & abolish rules on mitigation & other destructive efforts is NOT POPULAR.  See https://www.eenews.net/energywire/stories/1060113599?t=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.eenews.net%2Fstories%2F1060113599

Democrats Way Too Low a Bar for Interior Nominations: A recent report suggests that Democrats such as Raul Grijalva (NM) Jared Huffman (Cal.) are willing to accept Rob Bishop as a replacement for Ryan Zinke & Susan Combs as assistant secretary for policy, management and budget, justifying their support by stating that “You could do worse!” Their only reason offered is that they don’t have “the legal baggage” that those who are already. Their position is totally unacceptable to anyone who cares in the least for conservation. Bishop has been a consistent proponent for undermining the Endangered Species Act & also supports turning over Federal public lands to states. Combs has a terrible record undermining species protection in Texas that I have documented in my Wildlife Politics book (Cambridge University Press, 2017, p. 55).  The ONLY DIFFERENCE between them and Zinke is that they are MORE CONSISTENTLY opposed to the ESA—in other words far worse for conservation. Before his nomination. Bishop has tried to defund the National Landscape Conservation  system, supports the repeal system that allow states to overturn any Act of Congress, supports cutting Monuments & Antiquities Act that enables them. In other words, while Zinke claimed (falsely) to be a T. R. Republican, Bishop is the ANTI-Teddy Roosevelt Republican. In Texas, Rancher Combs handed over ESA protections to the oil industry & fellow ranchers. Her record on conservation could hardly be worse. How these Democrats can even suggest accepting these losers as replacements at Interior is beyond me! What the hell is going on here? I looked forward to Grijalva grilling Interior & USFWS over their anti-conservation policies & now they are willing to accept far worse!  Upsetting to say the least! For details of Democratic comments, see https://www.eenews.net/eedaily/2019/01/14/stories/1060111781

Bernhardt’s Opaque Interior: Rather than trying to be transparent, Bernhardt & Interior try to keep their stinky actions hidden & strive to achieve non-transparency. He never uses email or commits anything to writing to avoid accountability for pandering to energy industry. Now his Park Service is “muzzling” its superintendents so they don’t report on terrible conditions in parks due to shutdown. It’s time to get rid of Bernhardt, Acting Director, who is Acting to harm parks & public lands. See https://www.eenews.net/stories/1060111453

Bernhardt & Interior Dept is now ruled by long-temporary directors who have never received Congressional approval. Reasons for the delay? They are not qualified for their jobs—Susan Combs, e.g., is opposed to the Endangered Species Act but heads policy for the Dept. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2019/01/11/stories/1060111697

One more sneaky Bernhardt Action: Keeping Parks open despite shutdown. Bernhardt realizes that Americans value parks—not oil wells in a world overflowing with excess oil—so he keeps parks open illegally threatening safety of visitors & wildlife. Of course no public pronouncements or reasoned defense of these actions by Bernhardt or his lackeys. He is one sneaky son-of-a-____. For documentation,  see https://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/2019/01/11/stories/1060111729
 
Bernhardt Sneaky Evildoer, trying to Drill more Alaska Lands under cover: Bernhardt, Acting (hope that he never becomes permanent), found money to hold meetings to drill Alaska despite shutdown. When asked how he did this, his response was vague. One more example of the Bernhardt approach, try to sneak things by while never making anything public, keeping everything hidden. You don’t get many (actually any so far?) TWEETS from Bernhardt but you can be assured that he is working evil to Interior & public lands every day. https://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/2019/01/11/stories/1060111733

Utah Republicans: Federal public lands belong to Utah selfish interests—not to all Americans! Sens. Lee & Romney pushing bill to prevent new national monuments without state approval. These 2 & other State Republican leaders don’t belong to the same party as Teddy Roosevelt! In 50 years, which will we regret more—not leasing more land for oil-gas-coal or preserving lands for wildlife-conservation-& enjoyment of American public? See details of their destructive proposal at https://www.eenews.net/eedaily/2019/01/11/stories/1060111665

Bernhardt: Silent Killer of Wildlife & Environment: Bernhardt, Acting head of Interior, makes no pronouncements and tweets but he & his BLM are proceeding to destroy the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. BLM did an Environmental Impact Statement that proves very harmful impacts on wildlife. For example, In Chapter 3, page 111, it summarizers impacts on terrestrial mammals—they state there would be 12 Harmful Long-term Impacts. They also cite some “beneficial impacts” such as “early snowmelt due to dust deposition (great for animals!). They study 3 harmful alternatives (B,D, &D) but also list Alternative A which is to do nothing—Alternative A is far superior in every respect! See Volume 1 at https://eplanning.blm.gov/epl-front-office/projects/nepa/102555/164448/200585/Coastal_Plain_Draft_EIS_Volume_1.pdf
Despite these harmful impacts BLM has documented, Bernhardt, the lackey of energy companies that he has worked for while in and out of government, wants to push forward with the most harmful options. In short, Zinke is gone but Bernhardt is here & he’s WORSE THAN ZINKE
 
Some hope at last! With Dems taking over House, there are some positive news such as plan to review of 1872 Mining Act that prioritizes mining over other public land uses & doesn’t allow royalties be paid by hardrock mining companies. Also calls for research on effects of coal mining stopped by Trump.  Of course, Senate including Dem. Manchin loom but at least some light & perhaps news media will cover the harm being done by Trump-Bernhardt at Interior . See E&E News article at https://www.eenews.net/eedaily/2019/01/08/stories/1060111181

​After Zinke: Even Less Transparency at Interior & Now allowing more Methane pollution. They proposed new rules to reject FOIA requests they view as “burdensome”—i.e. anything that restrains energy dominance & destruction of public lands-oceans. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/12/28/stories/1060110661  For info on their rolling back rules on Methane leaking that is proven to harm public health, see great New York Times article at https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/12/26/us/politics/donald-trump-environmental-regulation.html?emc=edit_th_181227&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=103654191227
​

Utah, Reveals Hypocrisy: Utah, the state whose politicos support destruction of monuments—prioritizes keeping National Parks open! Gov. Herbert says “we don’t like having to do it—The Federal government should be doing it.”  Does this show that despite their consistent support of state-private takeover of public lands & politicians like Rob Bishop who want to destroy the Endangered Species Act (ESA), that their numbskull politicos realize that their well-being & the state’s health depends on NATIONAL PUBLIC FEDERAL conservation? No, I guess that’s expecting too much from these dopes! See Alan Blinder https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/24/us/shutdown-states-national-parks.html
​

Post-Zinke Trump Department of Interior:

Post-Zinke #2: Bernhardt, Zinke’s Deputy, who now appears to be Acting Sec. of Interior, has FAR more conflicts of interest than Zinke. He had to cancel speech on water issues in Colorado because it conflicted with his previous job with a law & lobbying firm that conflicted with actions to be taken by the Colorado River District. He represented Westlands Water District that seeks to weaken ESA—a position which Bernhardt has supported—one more example of him shelling for former clients. In short, his history reveals that he is an oily, disgusting creature straight out of the swamp. He should not be Acting Secretary, much less the permanent Secretary of Interior.  See https://thinkprogress.org/interior-deputys-long-career-as-a-lobbyist-creates-headaches-for-departments-ethics-officials-20c5b902b8b0/

Post Zinke #1: Why David Bernhardt, likely Acting Secretary of Interior after Zinke booting, is even worse! Zinke at least stated he was “TR Republican” & against selling public land. Bernhardt is committed to weakening (destroying) the Endangered Species Act—like Zinke he cares only about energy dominance.  He’s a swampy energy lobbyist who has gone back & forth between govt. & industry and tried to sell land in Grand-Escalante monument which later had to be reversed due to public outcry.  Finally, he is slippery trying to escape being caught by NEVER using email or committing any of his evil decisions to paper. In short, like Wheeler replacing Pruitt at EPA, Bernhardt is merely a sneakier, smoother evil man who will do ever more harm to conservation, wildlife, public lands and oceans.
Documentation of above points: Anti-ESA at https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/at-interior-were-ready-to-bring-the-endangered-species-act-up-to-date/2018/08/09/2775cd8e-9a96-11e8-b55e-5002300ef004_story.html?utm_term=.3121b88d5c9b&wpisrc=nl_headlines&wpmm=1 Trying to sell Grand Escalante: https://www.lcsun-news.com/story/news/local/2017/08/24/las-cruces-area-leaders-decry-zinke-summary-await-organ-mountains-desert-peaks-national-monument/600042001/  His secrecy at: https://medium.com/westwise/joel-clement-interior-whistleblower-podcast-interview-db219d9a1a3a
​

Below are 224 Reasons why Zinke deserved to be booted and why he was the Worst Secretary of Interior Ever.​  In his short term in office, Ryan Zinke has proven that he is the worst Secretary of Interior ever—far worse even than James Watts. He is undermining wildlife conservation—almost every day he takes some action that harms wildlife and those trying to preserve it. This terrible record has been achieved in just a few months and, unfortunately, he will be making additional attacks on wildlife conservation references supporting each point. Each new day brings more Zinke attacks on wildlife conservation & the environment so I am adding the most recent ones to the top of this list:

Reason 224: Zinke’s friends, Trophy hunters & NRA are appealing protections for grizzlies near Yellowstone Park—same area where they recently killed daughter of renowned wolf. It’s time for majority (surveys show this is fact) to reject this tiny but powerful pressure group. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/12/14/stories/1060109727
 
Reason 223: Zinke’s BLM to sell public land important to conservation to company that that harmed it without permission.  Their logic? Since the company destroyed the public land, it is “difficult and uneconomic to manage.”  Think about that—Zinke is willing to allow lease public lands to companies for exploitation & wans to do the same to ANWR. Then he uses the destruction  of the quality of the pristine habitat as an excuse to sell it. See https://www.huffingtonpost.in/entry/blm-ryan-zinke-federal-land-sale-california-limestone-quarry_us_5
c11a809e4b002a46c13f3f7

Reason 222: Zinke cares about Big Game Hunters--& Only about Big Game Hunters! In one of his tiny number of wildlife actions, Zinke's BLM is purchasing a thousand acres in Montana with $ from Land & Water Con. Fund to improve access to public lands for big-game hunters. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/12/11/stories/1060109317

Reason 221: Zinke versus Transparency: Zinke, Liar Extraordinaire, just changed FOIA requests to a staff person who is yet to be nominated! Way to go Stinky Zinke—freedom of information on what you are doing to public lands would be the Kiss of death! The main in charge of FOIA is a Koch brothers flunky who cut protections for migratory birds.  See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/12/11/stories/1060109315 and also https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2018/12/ryan-zinke-getting-interior-to-respond-to-your-foia-requests-just-got-a-lot-harder-daniel-jorjani/

Reason 220: Zinke’s willful ignoring of science: Interior will now open millions of sage grouse habitat to drilling. Scientific experts state that this policy is not based on “any science” & overturns a compromise reached by Fed., State agencies, industry, & conservation groups that took years to achieve. Indeed, this compromise is so fair that one conservative Republican state (Montana) reportedly intends to retain the Obama regulations. It is one more proof positive that Zinke doesn’t care in the least about the bird that he “loves more “than anybody.” In short, Zinke proves once again he is a bald-faced liar as well as destroyer of conservation & endangered species. For details, see https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/06/climate/trump-sage-grouse-oil.html?emc=edit_th_181207&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=103654191207

Reason 219: Zinke-Murkowski Move to Destroy ANWR:  NYT article details how combination of Zinke & oil industry execs working in Interior, Lisa Murkowski & Native Amer. Corporation s (ASRC)tanding to make billions are rushing to drill ANWR along with road-building, & are cutting way back on environmental impact analyses.  As customary in Zinke Dept., Interior staff heading the effort have previously worked for the organizations that will benefit from the drilling. Many leaders & shareholders of ASRC are not Native Americans. Other Native American groups oppose the drilling. ASRC has donated heavily to Murkowski.  In short, Zinke continues his SWAMPY decisions, ignoring conservation & environment, to benefit industry that has donated to him & whose employees he has put in place as high deputies. For detailed article in NYT, see https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/03/us/oil-drilling-arctic-national-wildlife-refuge.html?em_pos=medium&emc=edit_sc_20181204&nl=science-times&nl_art=4&nlid=10365419emc%3Dedit_sc_20181204&ref=headline&te=1

Reason 218: More on Zinke’s Ethical Misdeeds: See the details on how Zinke helped out chairman of Haliburton oil services company in an article by Aaron Weiss. Main takeaway?: Lock him up! See https://medium.com/westwise/the-interior-secretarys-latest-microbrewery-denial-is-a-howler-d80f6db45ae5
 
Reason 217: Zinke Advisory Boards Couldn’t Care Less About Conservation. His original Citizen Advisory Board quit—he never even met with them. His Intl. Wildlife Council is filled with trophy hunters. His new Advisory Board is composed of members who lack any commitment to conservation & wildlife—and are totally white and, of course, Republicans. Their supposed “qualifications” for this committee are in order: Republican Miss. Mayor who served Koch Brothers ALEC Council, member of Jesse Helms staff, member of Medical Services industry, member with “Business Management & Private Sector Experience, member with Business Development & “private sector experience,” member with “Business Development & Private Sector experience,  Psychologist, member from Medicine, Seller of Anheuser Busch products, a specialist in entrepreneurship, & Business Development and Private Sector experience. See the full details at https://www.nps.gov/resources/advisoryboardmembers.htm

Reason 216: Zinke Ethics Report #2: Zinke’s staff dominated by extractive ind. Officials (See Reason #22). Early count total 21 from industry-Drain the Swamp???—Bull____!  He sold vehicle at low cost violating ethics & has abused travel as Sec. taking unnecessary expensive helicopter flights (Reason #45). He took huge $ from extractive as Cong. (Reason 33). His PAC used unethical acts to get donations from small donors—his PAC formerly headed by Exec. Who was guilty of child pornography! (Reason 41). 

Reason 215: Zinke-Trump versus Republican G.H.W. Bush Administrations: I just read note of how H.W. Bush promised “no net loss of wetlands” as a goal. Contrast with Zinke-Trump: Maximize Energy Dominance Via Turnover of Public Lands to Oil-Gas-Coal-Cows. Sad—Many Republicans used to care about conservation. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/12/03/stories/1060108603

Reason 214: Zinke, Listen Up You Dope: The real story on Cal. Forest fires: lack of prescribed burns allowing growth of small trees—logging is not a solution—Logging takes the bigger trees. 40% forests are private land. Another major problem: More & more people want to live near the wooded land putting them at risk from nature fires plus most fires are now have human causes. Finally, climate change has had major impact. So, next time you “advise” that other famous ignoramus (Trump) on fires, provide him facts, not fiction. See documentation for these points in New York Times Magazine article by Ngu & Chinoy at https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/11/29/opinion/sunday/california-wildfires-forest-management.html

Reason #213: Zinke ethics report  #2: Zinke removed a hurdle for controversial Mojave Desert Cadiz project which his Deputy Sec. will benefit from (See Reason 36), Zinke lied about claims for energy production (#28), Zinke received 350K in last 2 years in Congress from Energy industry (Reason 33). For Documentation: See #213 at https://www.wildlifepolitics.org/blog

Reason 212: Zinke versus Science & Ethics Report #1:  like Trump, Zinke denies climate change while Scientists in Trump Administration issue report demonstrating it & harmful effects it will have.  This is the same Zinke who purports to be an expert on forest fires. 75% of his employees say they are unable to make decisions due to “political considerations” (see Reason 182 for details).  Example: his staff ignored science-based info on threat to Pacific Fishers in order to cater to industry (see Reason 169 for details). He ignored scientific data in drawing back on Migratory Bird Treaty Act—again due to energy industry (see Reason 156). He forces U.S. Geological Survey scientists to get approval before talking with reporters because Zinke doesn’t like to see his lies contradicted by facts (see Reason 129). Zinke halted study into link between surface mining & health and says Interior will no longer use science-based “guidance documents” to carry out laws (see Reason 124). Zinke’s BLM blocked their archaeologists from speaking at science conference--from testifying problems of leasing lands rich in archaeology & failure to protect cultural resources valued by tribes (see Reason 114).  Zinke has altered scientific reports to omit human role in climate change, unprecedented political interference in government science at the Interior Department, which oversees the park service (see Reason 109). Zinke’s rushed to turn over public lands to oil-gas-coal ignored science & NEPA (See Reason 87).  Zinke ignored science in favor of politics in giving grants…Interior now funnels grants through a political screening intended to ensure the federal dollars "better align" with the administration's "priorities" (see Reason 74). Zinke ignored science in revoking mitigation policies to compensate for harm done to the environment (See Reason 70). Zinke’s Department ordered the National Academies study on the safety of offshore drilling to be stopped (See Reason 66).  Zinke punished Interior Department employees for making science-based statements about the harm that climate change will wreak on national parks (See Reason 64).  Zinke is opening BLM to more ORV use in sensitive areas which threatens archeological sites but is also very harmful to wildlife as has been proven by scientific research (See Reason 24). Zinke focused on sage grouse populations instead of habitat conservation and proposes using captive breeding to support sage grouse—both approaches are discredited by science (see Reason 8). 

 
Reason 211: The Zinke-Trump Energy dominance mania threatens energy infrastructure, making it harder to drill-mine coal & deliver through pipelines, affect water necessary for fracking, make oil pipelines vulnerable to melting permafrost, & reduce capacity of power grid. See https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/29/climate/trump-energy-dominance.html?emc=edit_th_181130&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=103654191130


Reason 210: Zinke versus Science & Professionalism: Like Trump, Zinke rejects science, denies climate change, and makes it impossible for professional and ethical employees to do their job when they believe in science & climate change. The top National Park Service official resigned her  job due to support work addressing its impacts. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/latest-top-national-park-service-climate-official-resigns?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 209: Zinke Lead bullets & Lead in his head: One of the first actions of Ryan Zinke was to allow lead bullets on Federal land—an action banned by the Obama Admin. Evidence continues to mount about the harmful conservation & health effects of lead bullets. This is one more example of Zinke ignoring science, demonstrating his stupidity & subordination to the gun lobby. See Ian Urbina A Clean Shot: Urging Hunters to Try Unleaded Ammo. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/24/us/ammunition-lead-bullets-condors.html

Reason 208:  Zinke-Republicans Still At It (despite trying to survive ethical transgressions scandal) trying to kill species & conservation. Zinke’s BLM is trying to evade court order to protect sage grouse by allowing tens of thousands of acres for oil-gas industry. Zinke & Republicans want to kill wolves—Republicans just passed bill to remove protections for gray wolves from Endangered Species Act. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/11/16/stories/1060106493
https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/11/16/stories/1060106489

​Reason 207: Despite evidence of world wide threat to species. Zinke has not only done nothing—he has taken steps to threaten endangered species more. For example, allowing importation of lions & other trophy animals & restrictions on protecting migratory birds, cutbacks in protections for sage grouse, cuts in budgets & staff for conservation agencies such as USFWS, and total dedication of public lands for energy development & welfare rancher cows.  The threats to species are increasing daily due to human population increases, development, & agriculture as a recent World Wildlife Study showed but Zinke is making the matters much worse. For documentation of above, see:
Crisis for Endangered Species: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/2018/10/millions-of-years-mammal-evolution-lost-news/?us
er.testname=none&fbclid=IwAR27UxeSUrhoZNCBT6lnq6_svgTq_2OhqYIyZGkH-kks-3I1mAh33OMuI8s
Sage Grouse: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/27/climate/trump-fracking-drilling-oil-gas.html
Trophies: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/steven-chancellor-lion-trophy-import-permits-ryan-zinke-advisory-council_us_5bd78157e4b017e5bfd4dfaf
Migratory birds:  http://www.timberjay.com/stories/twin-metals-decision-part-of-a-much-broader-initiative,13850
Budget cuts: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/interior-department-reorganization-hearing_us_5a295068e4b0fa798612887f

The New West Shows Up At the Polls! Watch out welfare ranchers! The most heartening news for those of us interested in conservation & public lands is that in several western states traditionally dominated by energy-rancher-owned politicians, several conservation-oriented candidates won notable triumphs in Utah, New Mexico, and Nevada & other states:  
Arizona: Tom O’Halleran,
California: Repr. Harley Rouda,
Minnesota Governor: Tim Walz
Nevada: Repr. Jacky Rosen, Repr. Susie Lee, Repr. Steven Horsford, Governor Steve Sisolak
New Mexico: Repr. Xochitl Torres Small, Land Commissioner Stephanie Garcia Richard
Montana: Sen. Jon Tester,
New Mexico: Sen. Martin Heinrich, Governor: Michelle Lujan Grisham
South Carolina: Repr. Joe Cunningham,
Utah: Repr. Ben McAdams, San Juan County Commissioner Willie Grayeyes
Virginia: Repr. Elaine Luria
 
See the story of these candidates & other results  at https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2018/11/13/460797/conservation-ballot-public-lands-waters-won/

Reason 206: Interior Department versus Transparency: Zinke has tried to keep his calendar secret to cover up his unethical meetings with energy companies. His deputy (& likely successor) David Bernhardt never uses email & never writes anything down in order to avoid scrutiny & accountability.  We need the new House Committee on Natural Resources to conduct detailed investigations in which they put Zinke (if he is still around) and Bernhardt under oath for detailed questioning that will be required to reveal their ethical & legal transgressions for energy & other clienteles. See interview with Joel Clement at https://medium.com/westwise/joel-clement-interior-whistleblower-podcast-interview-db219d9a1a3a

Reason 205: Zinke is the Swamp! The Guardian just detailed examples of how his appointees consulted with industry (for whom they worked previously) to bias decisions about sage grouse protections, methane reg., & endangered species protect. He has attempted to cover up his “swampy” actions by lack of transparency, resisting providing details on his calendar & meetings. He exemplifies the corrupt public official, prioritizing his own & industry profits over public good. See https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/nov/12/the-zinke-effect-how-the-us-interior-department-became-a-tool-of-industry

Reason 204: Zinke has often spoken about Native Americans & tries to make it seem like he cares about them. But when their interests collide with Energy—Energy wins at it did when Trump-Zinke revoked Northern Bering Sea Protection that had been pushed for by tribal leaders—the Bering Sea Elders. See http://www.nomenugget.com/news/trump-issues-executive-order-revoking-northern-bering-sea-protection-and-tribal-participation

Reason 203: Zinke not only mishandles his job but documents show that he violated his ethics pledge. More importantly, he broke his promises to the citizens of Whitefish, Montana.  See https://www.washingtonpost.com/energy-environment/2018/11/05/newly-released-emails-suggest-zinke-contradicted-ethics-pledge/?utm_term=.a0ed392b79c3&wpisrc=nl_green&wpmm=1

Reason 202: Secrecy in Leasing Public Lands: Under Zinke Admin., most of the identities of people proposing oil-gas dev of public are unknown.  Now they don’t have to reveal identities—making it impossible to check on their stewardship & thus allow “bad actors” to ruin public lands with impunity.  See Lucy Livesay https://medium.com/westwise/whos-nominating-your-public-lands-for-oil-and-gas-leasing-d68af59a7025

Reason 201: Zinke often has to speak to and about Native Americans—but he never mentions how he ignored Native American input on Bears Ears & other environmental issue. Just one more reason why he deserves to be fired—which sounds increasingly possible. For Native American example related to the laughable attempt of a jackass Utah legislator trying to rename a highway through parks after Trump!:  see  https://www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2018/03/08/navajo-nation-leaders-oppose-naming-a-utah-highway-after-president-trump-calling-it-vengeful-hostile/

Reason 200: Zinke is overturning Federal regulations & ethical norms concerning predator control in Alaska. Former Alaskan Governor Tony Knowles described Zinke’s plan: attempting to rescind these regulations: "This is being done with no legal and scientific basis, minimal stakeholder involvement, and a hasty public process. One hundred and eight scientists, current and retired wildlife and resource managers, and many of the nation’s large carnivore experts, most with extensive experience in Alaska, have joined in sending a letter to Zinke adamantly opposing his action." Please read the article below & use its link to comment on Zinke’s latest horror. See
https://www.hcn.org/articles/opinion-interior-is-undoing-a-legacy-of-national-park-stewardship-in-alaska-predator-control?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 199: What’s top priority at Interior Dept.? Public Lands? Conservation? Wildlife? Nope. Coal. They are fast-tracking huge North Dakota project, ignoring evmntal issues.   Whatever happened to Zinke's touted "pivot to conservation."  He has pivoted--to destruction--of wildlife, public lands, & marine life. ​  See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/11/01/stories/1060104919

Reason 198: Zinke of necessity sometimes has to visit sites linked to Civil Rights figures. But he can’t hide his real feeling—his love for Confederate generals. In speaking at a Camp dedicated for Union soldiers, he compared Lee to Martin Luther King! How much more can this buffoon who is causing so much harm to conservation do and survive in his job?  See
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/ryan-zinke-robert-e-lee-martin-luther-king-jr_us_5bd8d090e4b01abe6a190bb4
 
Reason 197: Zinke’s finally getting just deserts—Justice to investigate him, Conn. sues Interior, Senators question why Zinke unable to fill advisory panels. In other words, the World is finally recognizing that he is not only unethical but incompetent. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/31/stories/1060104827
https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/31/stories/1060104825

Wildlife are cheering for Democrats to win House. It could save sea lions, sage grouse, Canada lynx, and many other species that Zinke’s actions are targeting. They are also cheering for the Justice Department to convict Zinke of ethical violations.  See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/30/stories/1060104719
https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/30/stories/1060104701
https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/30/stories/1060104709
https://www.washingtonpost.com/energy-environment/2018/10/30/zinkes-own-agency-watchdog-just-referred-him-justice-department/?utm_term=.7ca51069fd2e&wpisrc=nl_politics-pm&wpmm=1

Reason 196: Zinke’s original Citizen Advisory Committee quit. He has a much better relationship with his new “International Wildlife Conservation Council” (also known as Trophies on the Wall Council). One member, Steven Chancellor, a big Trump donor, has obtained permits from Interior to for 3 male lions (Wonder how he managed to obtain that permit!) He, like Zinke, has hundreds of trophies that he displays—too bad they have such a lack of manhood that they have to do this. See https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/steven-chancellor-lion-trophy-import-permits-ryan-zinke-advisory-council_us_5bd78157e4b017e5bfd4dfaf

Reason 195:  Zinke endangers endangered species—rather than protecting them. Interior tried to withdraw a plan to limit harm to marine wildlife by gill nets and Zinke’s Interior taking “another shot” at removing Hawaiian hawk from Endangered Species Act Protection. This phony “TR Republican” has undermined conservation of species every time it conflicts with industry or trophy hunters. He is not worthy to be in a Department that TR made significant. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/29/stories/1060104597
& https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/29/stories/1060104607
 
Reason 194: Zinke’s rush to lease Federal lands for short-term profits to energy companies results over long term, vistas of oil rigs, pollution of air, destruction of species like sage grouse, and huge consumption of water in arid region.  He is squandering public land & doing this by cutting requirements for careful study of environmental effects & ability to challenge them. Short-term gains for long-term devastation of public lands and wildlife—that’s the Zinke-Trump way. See New York Times story at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/27/climate/trump-fracking-drilling-oil-gas.html

Reason 193: Greenwire reports a big morale drop at Interior. This blog already detailed why this occurred in Reason 182—professionals think politics is dominating decisions & they are not allowed to communicate with the public. Indeed, if you check out the 192 reasons below, you will see that anyone who cares about conservation, the environment, wildlife, public lands, and oceans would despair working for someone who only cares about making his energy, ranching, & trophy hunters happy. Although Trump will nominate another loser, it’s time for accountability of Zinke’s terrible actions & thus for this liar to go. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/26/stories/1060104513

Reason 192: Zinke appoints “The Worst of the Worst”: Zinke appointed Karen Budd-Falen as “Solicitor for wildlife and parks.” Her qualifications? She holds that grazing livestock on public lands is “a private property right” & tough if there are any negative effects on wildlife & biodiversity. She supports miner who bulldozed wilderness area & landowners who did not believe they had to follow tag limits because this was “unconstitutional limits” on their right to property. In other words, forget about conservation, property rights trump protections for public lands & species. The Worst of the Worst. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/sagebrush-rebellion-sagebrush-rebel-karen-budd-falen-appointed-to-interior-department?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 191: Zinke’s USFWS is failing in its job to protect species. Why? Zinke’s top priority is energy company support & protections for any species could threaten that priority. His second priority is for developers—especially those with ties to Zinke and/or other wealthy Republicans. His third priority is trophy hunting—his few wildlife actions have all been to provide access for trophy hunters & some protection for migrating big game species. A Center for Biological Diversity analysis shows Zinke is withholding protection for 78 species. Non-game species—mean nothing to Zinke and apparently to any other USFWS employees. It is incumbent on reporters to ask Zinke USFWS appointees (e.g., Skipwith) what they have done for such species! Skipwith wants to compete with Teddy Roosevelt for protection of species! She is now working for a Department that is doing for wildlife what Hitler did for Jews!  See https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/news/press_releases/2018/endangered-species-10-18-2018.php/?utm_source=eeo&utm_medium=email

Reason 190: Zinke just approved first oil-gas drilling in Arctic off Alaska coast, arguing that it would be “good..for American energy dominance…and the environment”!!!  Having pushed to destroy wildlife on Alaskan lands such as by drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and shooting denning cubs & pups in NATIONAL wildlife refuges, he now is moving onto destroying Alaskan waters and the wildlife they support. He statement is such a huge, bald lie that it truly matches the Trump-Hitler approach: the bigger the lie, the better. See https://www.washingtonpost.com/energy-environment/2018/10/24/trump-administration-just-approved-plan-drill-oil-alaskas-federal-waters-its-major-first/?utm_term=.8fa11733299a

Reason 189: Zinke’s cutting Sage Grouse Habitat is illegal. A Federal judge just ruled that BLM must stop oil-gas leases on 1000s acres! He’s not as happy with Zinke End. Species policy as Skipwith--his new pick for USFWS (see below). As you know, Zinke abrogated a compromise worked out over several years by Federal, state, energy sector, and conservationists merely to please the energy industry.  T.R. Republican! B.S.!!! See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/24/stories/1060104215

Reason 188: Zinke nominates another industry hack to head USFWS. Aurelia Skipwith’s statement of acceptance stated that she wanted to “ensure implementation of …Zinke’s policies to protect species…ensure science..at forefront..achieving a legacy second only to President Teddy Roosevelt.”!!! Does she live in this universe? See 187 reasons below why Zinke is the antithesis of Teddy Roosevelt, has NO interest in saving species except for TROPHIES. He has banned climate change from Interior discussions. She starts off her “career” as competing for the TOP LIAR of Zinke’s very dishonest staff! See https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/412660-trump-to-nominate-former-monsanto-exec-to-top-interior-position

Reason 187: Zinke has not only rejected science such as climate change but now is trying to hide from the transparency required by the Freedom of Info. Act. concerning the Endangered Species Act (ESA) & other key issues. Zinke knows he can’t stand up to honest scrutiny so he tries to hide his actions against ESA & wildlife conservation secret. He once more proves that Mr. Macho Navy Seal is actually a coward. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/oct/18/trump-administration-us-endangered-species-discussions-secret
 
Reason 186: Trump moves to protect Zinke whose unethical practices are being reviewed by placing a political appointee to act as the "watchdog for Interior"—usually this is a nonpartisan job. The inept & corrupt Zinke can’t face fair inquiry so Trump tries to save him. See the Washington Post article at https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/hud-political-appointee-abruptly-moved-to-lead-interiors-watchdog-office-amid-ongoing-investigations-into-zinke/2018/10/16/30de03b4-d164-11e8-83d6-291fcead2ab1_story.html?utm_term=.84662dd52870  Note: After this was posted, Trump & Interior receive very negative reactions so they apparently scuttled the plan. Nevertheless, HUD didn't do this on their own without agreement from Zinke so it shows that Zinke is out to eliminate any fair review of his dirty deeds. 

Reason 185: Zinke is a Dope. His idea of using military bases to supply energy for export has been exposed as “harebrained” and “half-cocked” by knowledgeable officials.  They derided the idea of exporting coal when demand for it is expected to fall drastically. Even energy industry officials characterized the idea as “stretch.” Furthermore, Zinke has not consulted with states about this harebrained idea—funny when he criticized Obama for pushing Federal policies onto states without consultation. In short, Zinke has proven once more that he is incompetent—witness Congress’s total rejection of his proposed Interior budget cuts & states resistance to his wish to drill in U.S. coastal areas. In short, he is a dope who lucked into a job because he once happened to say he was a “Teddy Roosevelt Republican” and supported public lands—both of which he has proven to be HUGE lies. For documentation of his harebrained military base scheme, see https://www.politico.com/story/2018/10/15/zinke-energy-export-plan-848856

Reason 184: Zinke keeps his calendar vague to cover up his meetings with lobbyists representing energy industry corporations, the NRA and private vendors seeking to dominate public parks. This goes against the common and ETHICAL PRACTICE of providing detailed calendars and once again proves that Zinke is not fit for any office & certainly one that is supposed to protect public lands & wildlife. See https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/13/politics/ryan-zinke-calendars-interior-secretary/index.html

Reason 183: Count on Zinke to hire the Worst! He just appointed Karen Budd-Falen as “Solicitor for Parks & Wildlife.” Her qualifications: She represents welfare ranchers in their fight against preservation of species such as the desert tortoise & favors private property rights. In other words, she opposes conservation & public lands. One more example of Zinke-Trump handing over government to people who oppose the functions they are supposed to be carrying out. Impeach Zinke! Impeach the creep!—I don’t think there is any other language to describe him.  For documentation, See https://www.npr.org/2018/10/15/657542759/critic-of-federal-public-lands-management-to-join-department-of-the-interior

Reason 182: Interior employees say that politics is dominating Zinke-Interior actions. 55 percent believe that “resource allocations” are directed away from those whose  work is “politically contentious” such as those that that threaten powerful interests like energy industry and developers. 50 percent say that their ability to communicate with the public about science has worsened under Zinke. 75 percent agree that “consideration of political interests” has hindered the ability of the agency to make “science-based decisions.”  See https://www.ucsusa.org/center-science-and-democracy/promoting-scientific-integrity/scientist-survey-2018#.W79so2hKiUn

Reason 181: Zinke claims success due to sale of oil and gas leases in New Mexico but the data show that actually most of the public lands that Interior is trying to lease to energy industry attract no bids at all while the costs to the environment of their craze to give public lands over to industry are threatening priceless areas such as Utah’s Canyonlands National Park and Arizona’s Petrified Forest National Park. For details on Interior’s failures see https://medium.com/westwise/chest-thumping-interior-department-claims-one-success-amid-a-sea-of-losses-53c2abb0217a

Reason 180: Zinke has ordered Interior “not to settle” with environmental groups when they sue the agency over their failure to protect species and habitat. They argue envmntal groups are “lawsuit crazy” but the truth is that these groups usually WIN those suits because Interior has failed to act as they were supposed to. This action will delay needed steps to protect species & habitat and is being done for two reasons: (1) It will delay actions that could impose costs on developers & industry that Zinke gives top priority to; (2) They will make it harder for these cash-strapped small groups to bring actions while opponents of protecting species & habitat, wealthy energy companies & developers have tons of money to pursue endless court actions. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/department-of-interior-issues-order-to-avoid-settlements-environment

Reason 179: Zinke brags about his mining ban near Yellowstone but “attempted to reverse a similar moratorium on uranium mining near the Grand Canyon” let a mineral withdrawal on Oregon’s Chetco River expire this summer. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/department-of-interior-zinke-announces-mining-ban-near-yellowstone?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
 
Reason 178: Zinke’s “conservation of game animals” is even flawed. The only wildlife issue that Zinke pays attention to concerns helping preserve game animals for trophy hunters & he recently has bragged about protecting their migration routes but actually his “actions” are phony—his “lease notice” restrictions don’t actually protect areas from industry. For full description of how his migration “protection” is phony, see Wyofile article: https://www.wyofile.com/as-zinke-touts-migration-safeguards-conservationists-protest/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=weeklynewsletter


Reason 177: One of Zinke’s first actions was to open public lands to use of lead bullets—overturning previous regulations while not disclosing his ownership of shares in a company that produces the ammunition. Research by Univ. of Minn. Found that 90 percent of raptors in their rehab center had elevated lead levels & 75% of bald & golden eagles suffer from high lead levels. Significant percentages of game birds in Utah & elsewhere have elevated lead levels. Non-lead ammo & fishing gear are now easily available, not much more expensive than lead gear, & perform as well or better. As usual, Zinke & NRA crazies can’t abide ANY RESTRICTIONS on guns or ammo. One more key fact: as a result of lead ammo & fishing gear, lead is showing up in human food. See documentation at https://www.hcn.org/articles/opinion-hunters-and-anglers-need-to-get-the-lead-out?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 176: Zinke & his Industry Minions in Interior “redact” information that disproves their reasons for cutting Marine Preservation Areas (MPAs) and National Monuments. Forced to respond to Freedom of Information Requests, they were forced to release documents that showed that harm to fishing industry was highly exaggerated from MPAs and that loss of archaeologically valuable sites and increased vandalism would occur due to cutting the monument. Interior wrote proclamations scuttling ocean sites. See Jennifer Yachnin, E&E News reporter https://www.eenews.net/stories/1060090197

Reason 175:  Zinke wants pesticides in National Wildlife Refuges. His Fish & Wildlife Service “revoked a 2014 ban” on use of neonics in them. Trump’s Interior department reverses ban of pesticides in wildlife refuges. Zinke’s “excuse” is pesticides are needed to “boost populations” of game species for trophy hunting, Zinke’s top priority (other than oil wells) for public lands. See https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/trump-s-interior-department-reverses-ban-pesticides-wildlife-refuges?suppress=true&utm_source=greenlife&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter


Reason 174: Despite years taken by State Federal governments & input from industry & conservation orgs. Forest Service is making changes would reduce the size of priority habitat areas and some buffers around critical breeding sites, as well as potentially ease oil and gas development in grouse habitat. The agreement was perfect example of COMPROMISE. Not enough for Zinke & his industry-minions who rule Interior. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/10/05/stories/1060100677
​
Reason 173: Zinke deliberately ignores Native Americans on Bears Ears. He ignored Native Americans objections to his Bears Ears decision saying that he was a “facts guy.” Actually, a group of Native Americans, mainly Navajos, had gathered extensive data on cultural and historical lands that could be lost to Zinke’s change in Bears Ears. A Councilman from the Havasupai Tribe pleaded for maintaining a moratorium on mining due to threats from poisons passed down to them by the river.  Zinke named the northern part of Bears Ears “Indian Creek” which shows either ignorance or deliberate malice towards the Native Americans. He named the southern area using the Navajo “Shash Jáa” but there are five tribes in the area and each has its own name for it. Native Americans believe he chose the Navajo name as a means to dividing the tribes. In short, Zinke deliberately ignored and insulted Native Americans in his so-called “fact-finding” and subsequent decision on Bears Ears. See https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/2018-4-september-october/feature/land-grab-trumps-campaign-against-bears-ears-national?suppress=true&utm_source=greenlife&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter  and https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/what-s-in-a-name-bears-ears-national-monument?suppress=true&utm_source=greenlife&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter

Reason 172: Zinke’s Interior Department does not take necessary steps to protect public lands & rivers even if they are important. Oregon Chetco River  runs through or near Kalmiopsis Wilderness. Oregon has tried to have the river protected but Zinke & Republicans in Congress never did anything so the river now will be open to mining. No formal statement has been made by Zinke but his consistent favoring of oil-gas-mining on or near beautiful Federal lands makes clear his priorities—they don’t include protecting public lands, rivers, oceans even if they are beautiful. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/rivers-and-lakes-on-one-of-oregons-wildest-rivers-mining-protections-lapse

Reason 171: Zinke wants to destroy another monument! He wants to open the Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument to fishing. This monument provides habitat for endangered sperm whales and huge cold-water corals. It was created by Obama which makes it a top target for Zinke-Trump.  See http://www.nationalmemo.com/interior-secretary-would-open-atlantic-marine-preserve-to-commercial-fishing/

Reason 170: Zinke wants to destroy conservation in Samoa, too: Not content to attacking national monuments like Bears Ears at home, Zinke was heard on his recent trip to Samoa telling them that he & Trump were committed to opening the Rose Atoll Marine National Monument to commercial fishing—violating rules that make these monuments protective of fish & biodiversity. No matter where he goes, you can count on Zinke to do harm to conservation. See https://www.saipantribune.com/index.php/something-is-fishy-with-zinke/

Reason 169: USFWS under Zinke ignores science that shows species such as Pacific fishers are endangered. USFWS used to be composed of professionals dedicated to the Endangered Species Act. Now working under Zinke who considers it the top priority for Interior to cater to industries, they cater to logging industry by minimizing evidence that the fishers are threatened by poisoning—changing the position held by USFWS under Obama. Zinke doesn’t trust any employees who don’t follow his priorities & USFWS has got the message—forget about ESA protections if they “threaten” industries. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/endangered-species-judge-to-the-fish-and-wildlife-service-dont-cherry-pick-science-pacific-fisher?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 168: In his never-ending quest to sacrifice the environment so as to reduce costs to the energy industry, Zinke’s Interior Department’s Bureau of “Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE)” (italicized to indicate this is now a false name for this agency—under Zinke’s it’s no longer dedicated to safety and enforcement but should be renamed “Bureau of Submission to Energy Company Desires”!) will remove “the mandate to have 3rd parties certify safety devices”—they will allow oil companies to “police themselves.” They will also no longer have to notify about “false alarms.” This shows once more that the Interior Department no longer serves the U.S. public—it’s now run by ex-energy company employees for the benefit of the energy industry.  See https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/408727-trump-officials-ease-offshore-drilling-safety-rule

Reason 167: Zinke ignores National Parks, Environmental Quality, Recreational Priorities, and Threats to Wildlife for mindless coal mine expansion near Bryce National Park.  Zinke’s BLM approved huge expansion of mine 10 miles from Bryce Canyon National Park that will affect the experience of park visitors and destroy breeding grounds of sage grouse. The expansion would increase coal-mine related jobs by an estimated 240-480 but these job numbers are “dwarfed by those associated with Bryce.” See https://www.stgeorgeutah.com/news/archive/2018/09/03/jcw-blm-approves-lease-of-2114-acres-near-bryce-canyon-for-coal-mine-expansion/#.W6u0VWhKiUk and https://www.sltrib.com/news/environment/2018/07/13/there-will-be-eight-times/

Reason 166: News outlets report how Ryan Zinke told oil and gas industry: “Our government should work for you.” He tried to “clarify the meaning of this statement” but this is actually not news and not a surprise—he has proven it every day! All of Zinke’s top policy appointments have been to energy-ranching interests. Every major action he has taken is for energy-ranching-trophy hunting. For the “quote,” see https://www.vox.com/2018/9/21/17886538/ryan-zinke-interior-oil-gas-industry-environment

Reason 165: Zinke doesn’t want public input on leasing-auctioning of public lands—he is cutting the time for comments from 30-days to 10 days—the comment period in Obama was 60 days. And says he will not pay attention to most of them especially if they are from conservation groups. The only input he will listen to is “LOCAL” (i.e., industry) comments. See https://www.yahoo.com/news/trump-administration-rushes-lease-federal-lands-090041852.html?soc_src=social-sh&soc_trk=ma

Reason 164: Trump & Zinke hail work on Florence but coal ash spill pollutes the state and Republicans protect Duke Power Company & make customers pay for any cleanup of spills. This is what “energy dominance” does for states: Pollution for the public, profits for the companies. It’s the Zinke-Trump-Republican way. See https://www.newsobserver.com/news/local/article218718570.html & http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-florence-dam-breach-20180921-story.html

Reason 163:   Once again Zinke serves the  oil-gas-coal industry, not the U.S. public.  Zinke rolls back rules on methane. Obama rules would have reduced methane emissions by 182,000 tons a year. Zinke rejects science and evidence for climate-change which is harming many communities in the U.S. The change by Trump could save companies as much as $2 billion in compliance costs over the next decade. The change could also result in the loss of $734 million in natural gas that would have been recovered over the next decade under the old rule. Those savings would have offset some of the industry's compliance costs. An estimated $330 million a year in methane is wasted on federal lands, enough to power about 5 million homes. See https://phys.org/news/2018-09-trump-pollution-drilling.html

Reason 163:  Zinke rolls back rules on methane. Obama rules would have reduced methane emissions by 182,000 tons a year. Zinke rejects science and evidence for climate-change which is harming many communities in the U.S. Once again he serves oil-gas industry, not the U.S. public. See  http://pages.cdn.pagesuite.com/7/4/74aeee4a-9ee0-4347-a295-f980d61e541d/page.pdf

Reason 162:  Zinke-Trump Admin. oppose protection of wildlife such as Giraffes and Sea Otters. You can always rely on Zinke to do make the worst possible decisions concerning them—after all, he thinks the only worthwhile animal the one nailed to his wall. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/09/18/stories/1060098231
& https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/09/18/stories/1060098235

Reason 161: After putting up trophies of dead animals costing taxpayers thousands of dollars, Zinke opened up hunting at National Wildlife Refuges around the country. These are supposed to be WILDLIFE REFUGES, not Hunting Farms! Let’s get rid of this mindless trophy hunter. 

Reason 160: Zinke appoints temporary staff from energy industry who cannot & Don’t deserve permanent status, they make decisions favoring industry, but their harmful actions take hold anyway. This is illegal way that Zinke has been operating. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/09/12/stories/1060096755

Reason 159: Zinke recently bragged about the money he is making off auctions to oil & gas companies. The problem: Some of these are next to National Parks like Petrified National Park and his agency, BLM, did not give adequate time for the Navajo who lives in this area time to respond and oppose it. (Note: Zinke does pay attention to “locals”—but only if they are pawns of oil-gas-coal.) Just as in Bears Ears, he ignored Native Americans.  See https://www.eacourier.com/copper_era/news/blm-land-auction-opens-acres-to-oil-and-gas-companies/article_45fb7cac-b4b0-11e8-a862-c30aeec4ea3f.html

Reason 158: Zinke hands over wildlife to states—USFWS professionals & Endangered Species Act don’t matter anymore. EE news reports today that Individual states will wield more clout over fish and wildlife on about 780,000 square miles of Interior Department land nationwide under a new policy outlined by Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke. This follows his appointment of Anti-ESA to top staff positions, Susan Combs and Robert Gordon. States will do what they want—which in many states is make developers, industry, and ranchers happy. Wildlife & those concerned about them? Zinke doesn’t only not care—he is attacking them every chance he gets. For documentation, see https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/09/11/stories/1060096521

​Reason 157: Zinke is intent on destroying the End. Species Act. He previously hired Susan Combs, who led the Texas attack on ESA. Now he hires as her asst. Robert Gordon, an anti-ESA hack, who has worked for Heritage (anti-ESA org.) and Rob Bishop, author of much anti-ESA legislation. Rather than defend wildlife conservation, he is doing everything possible to undermine and destroy the Act which has served as the guidepost for saving species throughout the World. Zinke is a real and present danger to anyone who cares about public lands & conservation. For Gordon’s details, see http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/405146-zinke-hires-endangered-species-act-critic-for-senior-post

Reason 156: Zinke’s Interior is destroying the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. They are no longer prohibiting killing of birds if “the underlying purpose is not to take birds.” Even more so, they say that a disaster as big as Deepwater Horizon would not prosecuted under the Act—they would use another laws not specific to birds. In short, Zinke is undermining a law that almost dates back to the Teddy R. Admin. One more example of his pusillanimous backtracking on protection of birds & wildlife. This is not a partisan issue—8 states are taking the Admin. to court over the action and 4 of them are headed by Republican attorney generals. See https://www.washingtonpost.com/science/2018/09/05/eight-states-are-fighting-trumps-attempt-declaw-migratory-bird-treaty/?utm_term=.bbe6731b6cfa

Reason 155: Zinke promised transparency but delivers secrecy about who he is meeting with for what reasons. His calendars for his activities since May 2018 have provided only vague words about “internal briefings” and “external meetings.” Previous actions show that when Zinke fails to mention who he is meeting with, it is industry lobbyists. For example, in July his schedule said he met with Rep. Collins of New York but subsequently discovered that he also met with representatives of a tourism company “locked in a lawsuit” with Interior. No doubt these vague meetings are with his favorite industries (energy, welfare ranchers, trophy hunters, and private tourism companies that want to take over National Parks) as he doles out more goodies & favors to them. See https://www.cnn.com/2018/09/06/politics/interior-secretary-ryan-zinke-calendars-details-missing/index.html


Reason 154: Zinke nominates coal industry consultant & climate denier to head agency to monitor mines. Fortunately, the Office of Government Ethics raised ethical issues that J. Steven Gardner was unable to accept. Unfortunately, Zinke’s Interior Department has already “done away with that federal regulation, which sought to reign in coal mining operations in order to protect residents in vulnerable areas like Appalachia from documented health and environmental ramifications.” In short, not only does Zinke work against conservation, but also against the health of U.S. citizens. Some patriot! See https://thinkprogress.org/climate-denier-interior-mining-nomation-eadd7d82c1e8/

Reason 153: Zinke continues to appoint energy industry patrons to policymaking positions. His staff is totally populated with energy (and some ranchers). Zinke found another top staff person to his tastes, Greg Renkes, who had to resign as Alaska Atty General due to ethical questions about making a deal that benefited a coal company he owned stock in. He knows these people will be loyal—to the energy industry.  See https://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/06/us/alaskas-attorney-general-stepping-down.html

Reason 152: Zinke works for energy industry—they reward him & his staff with jobs when they leave Interior in return for policies sacrificing public lands & oceans to industry desires. His ex-energy adviser just took a job in offshore drilling. The Swamp of oil-gas-coal industry thanks Zinke again for his highly profitable service to them--quite a change from Obama era when Interior worried about conservation,  public lands & clean oceans. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/09/04/stories/1060095725

Reason 151: The Swamp is Worse than ever with Zinke in Charge. His appointees are nothing but lackeys for the industries they represent. Susan Combs represents ranchers & did her best to kill endangered species in Texas and let the oil-gas industry monitor their own compliance with rules protecting species such as the Sage Dunes Lizard. She took over Endangered Species protection in Texas with her Comptroller Department despite it having no expertise on conserving species at all.  David Bernhardt, his Deputy Secretary, is an oil-gas lobbyist who goes back & forth between industry & government, handing out favors to industry. His recently departed “Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy,” Downey Magallanes, is the daughter of a coal policy executive and worked to provide benefits to oil & gas industries as a Senate Staffer. She is now being replaced by Kate McGregor who likewise has made a career serving the oil-gas-coal industries as a staffer on the Hill. In other words, Zinke’s Interior officials go back & forth between industry and government jobs—where they push policies favoring industry. This is the essence of the Swamp behavior which (supposedly) Donald Trump opposes.   For documentation, see https://departmentofinfluence.org/person/downey-magallanes/ https://departmentofinfluence.org/person/susan-combs/  https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/07/30/stories/1060091613  & 
​​https://departmentofinfluence.org/person/david-bernhardt/

Reason 150: Zinke ignores both local and national “democratic” input and solid empirical evidence on superior benefits of monuments and conservation.  Example: When he considered the Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks National (OMDP) Monument, he admitted that comments were overwhelmingly in favor of retaining monuments but ignored them because they were “orchestrated.” But Zinke orchestrates private meetings with oil-gas-coal-welfare rancher industries & adopts policy to satisfy their interests religiously.  He skipped a National Monument Hall meeting packed with monument supporters. As has been shown in documents, his analysis of Bears Ears and other monuments ignored the major economic benefits gained by existence of monuments. His home state’s economic growth has been dominated by 5 countries growing quickly because they are nearby monuments. The western arid country public lands rancher industry that Zinke panders too is pathetic, unimportant to the nation’s meat production, unproductive, and would not exist without Federal subsidies. In recent days, information has surfaced that Zinke & his industry appointee (David Bernhardt) had to reverse a BLM decision to sell public land that was once protected inside the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. How did that decision happen? Well, since his appointment, BLM & the rest of Interior have learned that he kowtows to industry and, indeed, the decision was only changed after it got out & created an uproar. In short, Zinke ignores input and a mountain of evidence that monuments & conservation are economically superior to exploitation by the extractive and welfare rancher industries. For documentation on OMDP, see https://www.lcsun-news.com/story/news/local/2017/08/24/las-cruces-area-leaders-decry-zinke-summary-await-organ-mountains-desert-peaks-national-monument/600042001/ (2) For data on Montana economic growth, see https://headwaterseconomics.org/economic-development/trends-performance/montanas-economy-and-protected-lands/ (3) For documentation of his “reversal” on sale, see
https://www.washingtonpost.com/energy-environment/2018/08/18/second-thought-zinke-nixes-interiors-plan-possibly-sell-public-land/?utm_term=.0dc2e4590594&wpisrc=nl_green&wpmm=1
​

Reason 149: Ryan Zinke, who already heads Dept of Energy, Immigration Naturalization Service, & Dept of Interior, now has taken over as Trump’s Chief Climate Scientist. He has discovered that fires & other evils are caused by environmentalists. He has expert help-his football buddy with a bus. Admin. degree judges scientific merit of research. See https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/8/22/17767146/ryan-zinke-interior-climate-research-football-buddy
​

Reason 148: Conservation and preservation don’t hurt economies—they help them—perhaps too much! Zinke & Trump Admin. have fostered a false campaign that environmental protections hurt the economy and residents who live near protected areas.  Actually, there is a mass of evidence to show that quite the contrary is true: areas near protected areas gain economically from them. I have documented these in my Wildlife Politics book but 2 recent studies show the same truth. Development has occurred in Southwestern Utah near protected monuments and parks because people want to live there & new industries want to locate there. Indeed, San Juan County in southeastern Utah has complained about national monuments within its borders but are launching a new campaign by local officials to take advantage of these designated areas to help fuel the local economy. Indeed, development near protected areas throughout the world threatens the protection of wildlife and this is a fact not just in the U.S. but around the world as I document in Wildlife Politics. In short, Zinke & Trump’s campaign against conservation and environmental protection is based on a totally false premise—they help the long-term growth of the U.S. Yet, they are continuing to push on all fronts to undermine them through weakening the National Environmental Protection Act (which forces careful consideration before development), the Endangered Species Act, the Magnuson-Stevens Act (which protected against overfishing), expanding unproductive welfare ranching on public lands (which destroy the quality of the lands while providing wasteful subsidies to a very small largely well-to-do “ranchers,” allowing exploitation of public lands by extractive industries while lowering the revenues to be obtained from them. In short, Zinke-Trump are doing everything possible to provide short-term gains for selfish interests which will harm the long-term quality and economy of the nation. For recent documentation of the relationship between conservation & economic growth, see:  https://www.hcn.org/issues/50.14/growth-and-sustainability-in-southwestern-utah-unceasing-growth-means-increased-tension/print_view
& https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/08/20/stories/1060094727
​

Reason 147: Zinke is totally committed to energy dominance—he regards conservationists as “terrorists.” Not long ago, Zinke excited some “green groups” that he would be “pivoting to conservation” after spending the first year plus devoted to energy dominance & welfare ranching. He was sensitive about the contradiction between calling himself a “TR Republican.” In the period since then, he has doubled down on his total devotion to energy dominance and welfare ranching. At a recent conference, he called “conservationists” terrorists—so that is what he really thinks about Teddy R! His solution to wild fires—logging forests and having cows graze even more public lands. This is from the man who heads the Department that contains the Forest Service, National Parks Service, and Fish and Wildlife Service. Conservation has not only been abandoned by him—it is under constant attack from him & his extraction-rancher industry appointees. There is no alternative to preserve conservation but to remove this jackass from office. For account of his vision of “cows munching” and drilling of public lands, see https://www.hcn.org/articles/politics-as-ethics-questions-swirl-zinke-knows-how-to-work-a-crowd?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 146: Zinke & Republicans: Destroying National Parks, National Wildlife Refuges, & Public Lands. First, Cong. Republicans & Zinke allowed hunters in National Wildlife Refuges to kill wolf & grizzly cubs in their dens. Zinke wants the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge drilled. Now Cong. Republicans & Supreme Court want hovercraft in National Parks. This is Zinke-Trump-Don Young style “New Federalism”—the right of slob hunters & industries to kill & destroy wildlife & wilderness regardless of whether it is supposed to belong to the U.S. public. See doc. in previous Reasons for Killing in wildlife refuges & ANWR drilling—for hovercraft case see https://www.adn.com/alaska-news/2018/06/18/u-s-supreme-court-agrees-to-reconsider-case-of-alaska-moose-hunter-and-his-hovercraft/

Reason 145: Zinke & Interior Out to “Update” Endangered Species Act (ESA): Translation from “Republicanese” to Real English: They want to destroy it. Today’s Washington Post has opinion piece by energy lobbyist, David Bernhardt (now Zinke’s Deputy Secretary!) about how they will weaken protections on endangered species because, like patients in a hospital, they don’t need ongoing care. This is a false analogy for many if not most endangered species. Threats to their habitat are steady growing as population and development inexorably increases and a large percentage will require protections forever. They want to put “cost benefit” calculations into the determination of whether to save species which would undermine the incentives for developers, ranchers, and other selfish interests to create habitat conservation plans and reach compromises over protection of species like the sage grouse. Interior already has scrapped the Sage Grouse compromise which was a perfect example of the positive impacts of the ESA. Indeed, an ESA “updated” like the Republicans & Interior want would render the USFWS a “nothing agency”—states & local governments dominated by selfish local interests would do what they want with public lands and species. Professionals in USFWS should protest but either they have been forced out or resigned in protest or are afraid to speak up against Zinke-Bernhardt who believe that Interior’s main purposes are “energy dominance” and making welfare ranchers and trophy hunters happy. See Bernhardt’s “opinion” (i.e., unspeakable garbage) piece at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/at-interior-were-ready-to-bring-the-endangered-species-act-up-to-date/2018/08/09/2775cd8e-9a96-11e8-b55e-5002300ef004_story.html?utm_term=.3121b88d5c9b&wpisrc=nl_headlines&wpmm=1

Reason 144: Zinke hires the Worst such as naming Andrea Travnicek to oversee USFWS & NPS. She’s a lobbyist for coal and gas—thus he puts in charge people with interests OPPOSED to what they are supposed to do—conservation of species & public lands. See https://departmentofinfluence.org/person/andrea-travnicek/

Reason 143: Zinke versus Science: he wants to speed ANWR drilling before info on impacts ready. He squawks about fires but ignores climate change science that aggravates them. He is a “Know-Nothing” who has no business heading Interior. For documentation, see https://www.arctictoday.com/sped-timeline-make-drilling-alaskas-arctic-refuge-reality-prove-achilles-heel/

Reason 142: Zinke’s actions such as opening ANWR to oil drilling will leave lasting scars and ruin one of the few remaining wilderness areas. His “heritage” to our grandchildren is to destroy the nature that is become rare to non-existent. See New York Times story on how drilling has already left bad scars at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/03/climate/alaska-anwr-seismic-testing-tracks.html?emc=edit_th_180804&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=103654190804

Reason 141: Zinke deliberately sabotages Conservation. He is working to implement rules that will weaken the Endangered Species Act in coordination with Cong. Republicans. He is supporting cut of Land & Water Conservation Fund to 1% of its maximum. He removed rules that force miners and drillers to pay for damage to Federal lands. He has loosened import of trophies of endangered species. In other words, in EVERY case where there is a conflict between conservation and the desires of extraction industry, welfare ranchers, & trophy hunters he DELIBERATELY sabotages conservation. His tweets NEVER  speak out for professionals in Interior devoted to conservation but routinely laud law enforcement staff & anyone with ties to ranching & trophy hunting. See following sources for documentation of these points: https://www.hcn.org/articles/opinion-dont-let-politicians-kill-the-land-water-conservation-fund https://www.idahopress.com/eyeonboise/idaho-commission-says-wolf-livestock-kills-hit-record-in-past/article_76000591-8329-51cc-a607-634c899fb4e6.html  https://www.outsideonline.com/2327916/secretary-interior-ryan-zinke-scandal

Reason 140: Zinke punishes professionalism. He reassigns anyone who puts professionalism above priority of energy dominance & cows on public lands. He lauds only those involved in law enforcement functions or close relationship with his pals—extractive industries, welfare ranchers, & trophy hunters.  See one example at https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/employee-tapped-to-head-regional-national-park-service-rejects-transfer/article_d8a88d92-76a2-56b5-8974-8fe1f5364105.html

Reason 139:  Zinke gives more trophy hunting permits for lions but keeps the information hidden. There use to be country-wide policies but now done on “case by case basis” & they don’t let public know about them. Beneficiaries? Trophy hunters such as wealthy contributor to Trump. See https://www.newsweek.com/lion-trophy-hunting-permits-trump-1045891?utm_source=Twitter&utm_campaign=NewsweekTwitter&utm_medium=Social
​
Reason 138: Zinke’s BLM is ending the policy of compensatory mitigation for damage to habitats and endangered species.  His priorities are clear and warped. He says "mitigation is Un-American." So what is "American?"--doing everything possible to help extractive industries, developers, & ranchers and NOTHING for conservation and the public who want to preserve species and public lands. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/07/25/stories/1060091103

Reason 137: Zinke ignores information contrary to his positions, deliberately degrading the value of conservation.  He appoints extraction & rancher industry to top offices. He ignores local input that contradicts industry interests. An analysis by the Washington Post of thousands of emails by Zinke & his aides found that they systematically ignored evidence of the value of national monuments & conservation while emphasizing the “value of logging, ranching, and energy development.” In short, Zinke is dishonest & biased and not worthy of being the head of a Department that is supposed to protect public lands. See the article at https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/trump-administration-officials-dismissed-benefits-of-national-monuments/2018/07/23/5b8b1666-8b9a-11e8-a345-a1bf7847b375_story.html?utm_term=.29661ef938d1
And Rolling Stone article: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/ryan-zinke-trump-war-on-department-of-interior-700218/​

Reason 136: Zinke threatens to make the ESA a meaningless law. The very essence of the ESA is that conservation of species is a crucial value that should not be traded for profits by developers & state-local officials. Without that provision, the ESA becomes a meaningless law & selfish interests will do what they want. It also will make the USFWS a nothing agency. Any professional conservationist in USFWS should protest this change and resign in protest if it is not reversed. 

Reason 135: Zinke-Trump Pivot to Conservation: They want to destroy it. They want to strip the Endangered Species Act of key provisions that protect them regardless of economic impacts.  Implications: Whenever developers want to develop an area with protected species & habitat, states will be able to ignore threats to species if they consider the economic impacts more important. See 
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2018/07/19/endangered-species-act-stripped-of-key-provisions-in-trump-administration-proposal/?utm_term=.e428b0db7aef&wpisrc=al_news__alert-hse--alert-national&wpmk=1

Reason 134: Zinke’s so-called “Advisory Group” for parks is dominated by private industry that want to privatize park services such as a CEO who wants to “trademark” the name of Yosemite National Park! For a list of the members, see Secretary Zinke Selects Members of Newly Created “Made in America” Outdoor Recreation Advisory Committee
https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/secretary-zinke-selects-members-newly-created-made-america-outdoor-recreation-advisory
For a critique, see https://democracyforward.org/press/democracy-forward-sues-to-expose-zinkes-attempt-to-hand-over-americas-national-parks-to-his-corporate-allies-through-potentially-unlawful-committee/#.W04oi9JKiUl

Reason 133: Zinke is selling out public lands for lowered royalty rates from oil-gas-coal. Royalty rates haven’t increased for decades but Zinke is LOWERING them even further. Zinke revoked policy to follow science on climate change effects. Actually, the exploitation of lands is so unproductive that energy industry has failed to respond to lowered royalty rates & proposed sales.  Zinke ignores any consideration of conservation in decisions—only energy dominance & amount extracted matter. See the article by Zack Colman at https://www.revealnews.org/article/trump-dreams-about-a-new-energy-boom-oil-leases-could-cover-this-mountain-valley/

Reason 132: Zinke’s Cabinet, like him, consistently violate ethical rules Story by Huffpost shows Benjamin Cassidy, former NRA lobbyist, taking part in Interior decisions that he had previously lobbied for. Likewise,  his aide Todd Wynn scheduled meetings with his former corporation and Masburn attended events hosted by her former employer, Heritage Foundation. Finally, his Deputy, Bernhart met with Casino outfit represented by his former employer. Shows how an unethical leader like Ryan Zinke, hires personnel who replicate his “stinky” behavior. See https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/benjamin-cassidy-nra-interior-department_us_5b3fa5e9e4b05127ccf1bb2b

Reason 131: Zinke’s Interior produced 3 major attacks on conservation in one day (June 27th, 2018): 1. Allow Everglades highway across wetlands-See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/06/27/stories/1060086609
 (2) New plan to destroy red wolves; See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/06/27/stories/1060086631  (3) Boost oil-gas on shores-See  https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/06/27/stories/1060086645.  Just think about cumulative impact of 2/12 years more of Zinke-Trump on wildlife, public lands & sea shores. 

Reason 130: Zinke’s Interior Dept. brags about opening 10 Million Acres of Federal land to mining. It states that it is focusing on “economic development.” They say that “Federal lands belong “to every citizen” but Zinke cares only about mining industries & those citizens who will directly benefit from them. Most citizens favor protecting public lands for future generations but Not Zinke & Trump.  The funds that pay for Interior Department comes from ALL STATES—those containing the public lands that Zinke is handing over to industry pay a MINORITY of the taxes that support his Department. 

Reason 129: Zinke & Trump versus Science: Interior’s U.S. Geological Survey scientists must get approval before talking with reporters. Zinke & Trump don’t like to see their lies contradicted by facts. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/06/25/stories/1060086337

Reason 128: Zinke fires professionals & hires lackeys:  Zinke puts top Interior jobs in hands of those who support his (only priorities): oil, gas, coal, welfare ranchers, & trophy hunters. This is illustrated once again by his appointment of Dan Smith to replace Dan Wenk as Supt. Of Yellowstone. Wenk was unpopular with The Montana Group, Repub. lobbying org. that contributed to Zinke’s campaigns. They opposed free-roaming bison. Smith with an undistinguished career’s main “main achievement” was to “orchestrate” Wenk’s “reassignment” away from Yellowstone. See https://medium.com/westwise/former-yellowstone-chief-slams-secretary-zinkes-ousting-of-respected-yellowstone-superintendent-e28e21b93017

Reason 127: Zinke is The Swamp! Details have just emerged of how Ryan Zinke (and his wife, Lola) are engaged in a real estate deal with the Chair of Haliburton despite the fact that Zinke has made many decisions that enrich the company.  The article describes numerous other ethical violations by Zinke.  See https://www.politico.com/story/2018/06/19/ryan-zinke-halliburton-park-whitefish-montana-647731

Reason 126: What Zinke Cares About: Zinke never met with his Advisory group that was concerned with conservation but he is meeting again with his “Wildlife Conservation Council” dominated by trophy hunters. He knows what his priorities are: Killing trophy animals up at the top. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/06/18/stories/1060084913

Reason 125: Zinke has posted tweets about Native Americans. But he & Trump want to allow mining near Grand Canyon despite National Congress of American Indians has resolved against it & ignored the opposition of tribes to cutting of Bears Ears Monument. See https://www.hcn.org/articles/energy-and-industry-a-new-era-of-uranium-mining-near-the-grand-canyon?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email  and https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/13/climate/trump-uranium-bears-ears.html?_r=0

Reason 124: Zinke ignores science—Interior halted study into link between surface mining & health and says it will no longer use science-based “guidance documents” to carry out laws. See https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/09/climate/trump-administration-science.html

Reason 123: Zinke uses Advisory Groups dominated by Extractive Industries to propose reductions in royalty rates these companies pay for exploiting public lands—they are now proposing to reduce the rates even more—the Federal government’s rates are already far lower than what states like TEXAS charge.  These Advisory groups have little or no representation from the public or conservation-minded groups. Thus the Zinke-Trump Advisory groups are a perfect example of the SWAMP that hypocrite Trump complained about. See the details at: https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/green/news/2018/06/04/451582/secretary-zinke-poised-give-breaks-drilling-industry-less-oversight-public/

Reason 122: Zinke only wildlife concern is for trophy hunters. He loosened regs in Alaska such as use of blinding lights, baiting, dogs, killing pups in dens, indiscriminate traps & snares, despite overwhelming public opposition but then Zinke doesn’t care about public opinion-only trophy hunters. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/05/25/stories/1060082775

Reason 121: Zinke turns Interior into law enforcement agcy. He brags about Interior staff arrests & seizures at same time he’s cutting conservation staff & budget. When has he bragged or even talked about conservation? So much for pivot! See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/05/31/stories/1060083105

Reason 120: By time Zinke “pivots” to conservation, he will have destroyed public lands & oceans. He has cuts National Monuments, destroyed agreement to save the sage grouse and the Migratory Bird Act, opened Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to drilling, undermined protections against harm to public lands, and opened the entire U.S. coasts to drilling, just to name a few of his misdeeds.  For sage grouse,see https://www.hcn.org/articles/endangered-species-sage-grouse-shake-up-alienates-conservationists?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
For migratory, see Reason 76. For Bears Ears, see 60.  For drilling on land, see 59, for drilling on coasts, see 66 & 69 among others.  In short, “conservation” for Zinke is opening up U.S. public lands and waters to Donald Trump & his wealthy friends. 

Reason 119: Zinke thinks that the purpose of National Wildlife Refuges is to provide trophy hunters more killing opportunities. For example, he is opening up a Refuge in Philadelphia to bow hunters. His only mentions of wildlife during his term in office concerns using them as trophies. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/05/22/stories/1060082361

Reason 118: Zinke’s Desperate & False Move to Restore Credibility: After a full year of not only IGNORING conservation but taking numerous steps to undermine conservation and wildlife, Ryan Zinke just met with a number of “green organizations” and announced that he would change his focus “over the next few years” from energy towards conservation.  Why his Ryan Zinke doing this? Congress and the public concerned with conservation have been disgusted by his anti-conservation moves. Proof? Zinke tried to make HUGE cuts to the regular Interior Department budget but the Republican Congress rejected his cutbacks. Now he needs support from Congress and especially environmental organizations to achieve his proposed reorganization for Interior—a major purpose of which is to “streamline [translation: undermine] the National Environmental Protection Act” and ease rules on permitting!  Somehow he found 17.5 Million dollars in his proposed budget for this reorg. But his credibility is ZERO with environmental orgs.
 
Consequently, he is desperately trying to entice support. How? He makes a vague proposal to set up an “advisory group” to advise him on the reorganization. Reportedly many of the attending orgs. liked the idea of being on the Advisory group.  Although I understand why green orgs are desperate to get input and be able to tell their donors that they have “access to Zinke”, it’s a huge mistake to coddle up to Zinke who’s only interested in support for reorg.—not conservation. He ignored previous advisory groups so completely, they resigned in protest.
 
I suggest this to the environmental organizations: Agree to participate ONLY IF Zinke reverses the many harmful actions he has taken such as: (1) Reinstate the full Bears Ears Monument; (2) Get rid of anti-conservation staff such as rancher Susan Combs who hates the Endangered Species Act; (3) Reverse the decision to drill in coastal waters; (4) Support environmental regulations such as those to reduce Methane that he is trying to gut; (5) Make sure that oil-gas-coal development on public lands conform to existing NEPA rules that he is trying to undermine; (6) Ban use of lead ammunition on public lands—he cut regs on them; (7) Eliminate the International Wildlife advisory panel that is dominated by trophy hunters; (8) Enforce the ban on incidental killing in the Migratory Bird Act.  I could go on listing dozens more actions needed to reverse harm he has done to conservation but the above steps would be a good start and serve to show he is genuine about “pivoting to conservation.”  

Reason 117: Zinke, Congress, & State Departments of “Game” are failing to deal with Crisis of Huge Drop in Excise Tax for Wildlife Restoration Fund. New Data on Excise Taxes on hunting-angling shows HUGE decline in pistols-firearms-ammo revs-down 31%-33% from 2017. There also has been a long-term decline in hunters shown by 2016 USFWS survey. So what has Congress, Zinke, & states response been? They want to spend wildlife restoration $ to recruit new hunters! This a futile losing strategy. We need to get new revenue sources such as general tax funds which would be well justified—to preserve wildlife for future generations.  Expanded excise taxes on wildlife related activities such as Bird Feeding, binoculars, etc. would also make sense. At the state level, we also need new or expanded non-game-related revenue sources—some states have done a bit in this area but not enough & most states have done little or nothing. Instead, Congress is moving the WRONG way-their only action is to rewrite excise law (known as Pittman-Roberson) to allow use of wildlife funds to recruit new hunters! There also needs to be a total revolution in leadership of state agencies: I have been reviewing the leadership (e.g., directors and advisory commissions) for the state “Game” (tellingly, that is what a large percentage have in their titles) departments and not surprisingly, the leadership is overloaded with hunters with conservation-non-game interested people in a small minority in most states. Zinke is a total loss as a leader. Far from taking leadership for developing conservation of wildlife, he has demonstrated that he cares only about wildlife that can be used as trophies and he is going in the opposite direction from that needed. (See my blog’s Reasons #100, 99, 93, & 89 for documentation on Zinke trophy obsession).  The USFWS survey showed that more people are WATCHING wildlife and revenues related to wildlife viewing are INCREASING while revenues from hunting are dropping. This has been a LONG-TERM trend—it’s been going on for more than a decade and there is every reason to believe it will continue if not escalate. For data to support these points: see Wildlife Management Institute report on excise taxes (Note: they are a PRO-HUNTNG organization!)  https://wildlifemanagement.institute/outdoor-news-bulletin/may-2018/second-quarter-excise-tax-receipts-show-continued-drop-wildlife and the 2016 USFWS survey of wildlife related activities including watching and hunting, see https://wsfrprograms.fws.gov/Subpages/NationalSurvey/nat_survey2016.pdf

Reason 116: Like Donald Trump, this article shows Zinke continues to lie even after his lies have been exposed—claims that Bears Ears cut not related to drilling-mining. Like Hitler, they believe in BIG LIES—and unfortunately, they seem to get away with it. See https://medium.com/westwise/the-fix-was-in-emails-show-zinke-staff-focused-on-potential-for-drilling-and-mining-in-monuments-b24a735cb080

Reason 115: The Swamp Is As Big as Pacific Ocean under Trump-Zinke: Story tells how Interior official met with his former employer, conservative Koch-funded “foundation,” about job matters violating ethics rules. Interior spokesperson Health Swift lies as often as Sarah Huckabee Sanders & that takes some doing. See article https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/may/14/interior-department-official-koch-conflict-of-interest?CMP=share_btn_tw

Reason 114: Zinke-Trump’s War Against Science Continues: BLM blocked their archaeologists from speaking at science conference--from testifying problems of leasing lands rich in archaeology, failure to protect cultural resources valued by tribes, & need for better planning ahead of dev. rather than rely on “mitigation” that has proven to be failure in most cases. See https://www.sltrib.com/news/environment/2018/05/11/feds-blocks-government-archaeologists-from-speaking-at-a-major-science-conference/

Reason 113: Zinke puts people like Susan Combs in charge as Acting Assistant Secretary for Fish, Wildlife and Parks despite the fact that her “to save” endangered species like the Dunes Sagebrush Lizard in Texas allowed energy companies to self-regulate their efforts in such a flawed way that the State of Texas now has to redo the plan which does not monitor sand mining which is a major threat and she touted a “popular credit swap program” that was useless to saving the lizard—oil & gas paid contractors to remove mesquite but system provided no sig benefit for the lizard.  In short, Combs like Zinke does not care about conservation—her only goal is to avoid restrictions on oil & gas to improve their profits.  For detail analysis of Combs and Texas failings, see  https://www.mystatesman.com/news/state--regional-govt--politics/exclusive-citing-fatal-flaws-texas-rewrites-plan-save-rare-lizard/kpUCClUTA5Wov5JIj4NI3K/

Reason 112: Zinke’s BLM is giving a royalty rate reduction to Utah coal producer that will reduce federal & state funds by 19 million—coal is uneconomic to extract now so Zinke is subsidizing coal that pollutes streams, air, & land. See https://www.sltrib.com/news/environment/2018/05/07/feds-grant-utahs-largest-coal-producer-a-royalty-discount-worth-up-to-19-million/  No help to coal-gas-oil is too costly for Zinke—no efforts to preserve conservation & public lands is worthy of doing as far as Zinke is concerned. 

Reason 111: While Zinke continues to undercut and underfund conservation-related activities of Interior, he is now spending MORE resources on immigration! He is assigning more Park Service employees to protect the border even though this is the function of the Department of Homeland Security. This shows once again the utter bankruptcy of Zinke—he is actually opposed to protecting public lands & conservation—he cares only for oil, gas, coal, welfare ranchers, and trophy hunters. For story on assignment of NPS officers to immigration functions, see http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/386570-interior-is-sending-officers-to-assist-patrolling-the-us-mexico

Reason 110: Zinke's own state, Montana, rejects Zinke policies: Univ of Montana poll asked Montanans whether they approved or disapproved of Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke’s recommendations to decrease the size of national monuments. Of the respondents, 29% approved and 62% disapproved of Zinke’s recommendations. See https://news.umt.edu/2018/03/031418poll.php


Reason 109: Zinke has altered scientific reports to omit human role in climate change, unprecedented political interference in government science at the Interior Department, which oversees the park service, according an article in Reveal.  The article says that “Jonathan Overpeck, a climate scientist and dean of the University of Michigan’s School for Environment and Sustainability, said the deletions are “shocking from a scientific point of view, but also from a policy point of view.” And “To remove a very critical part of the scientific understanding is nothing short of political censorship and has no place in science,” he said. “Censorship of this kind is something you’d see in Russia or some totalitarian regime. It has no place in America.” See the full article at https://www.hcn.org/articles/corruption-human-role-in-climate-change-removed-from-science-report?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 108: Zinke is trying to kill a BLM rule that required oil & gas corps to repair leads of methane—even tho Senate voted this down. This change would save oil-gas lots of money but cause taxpayer to lose millions in royalty payments. Just one more example of how Zinke puts oil-gas-coal above conservation & public lands. ​

Reason 107: Zinke wants to remove the 4(d) rule that provides default protection to threatened species. This would result in the need for FWS staff to determine whether and what protections are “necessary and advisable” for each and every species listed as threatened. This is being done while Zinke has reduced staff & budget of USFWS. Note that Zinke rarely mentions conservation & if he does, it is coupled with plans to lease public lands to oil-gas-coal to obtain revenues to make up for Interior budget cuts he is making. In short, he is a disgusting hypocrite. See https://www.edf.org/blog/2018/04/19/zinkes-latest-change-endangered-species-act-more-trouble-you-think?utm_source=twitter&utm_campaign=edf_protect-and-defend_upd_dmt&utm_medium=social-media&utm_id=1524143345&utm_content=annie

​Reason 106: Earth Day under the Worst Environmental Admin. in History: Zinke’s hero, Trump, “celebrated” Earth day bragging about his cutbacks to environmental regulations—most of them done by Zinke or Pruitt: https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/04/23/stories/1060079821  Zinke is cutting charges to coal companies leasing use of public lands: https://mountainwestnews.org/study-wolverines-collar-humans-fecfbe3b7700  

Reason 105: Zinke’s Conception of Conservation: Mining helps the land!
Zinke thinks that Sage Grouse love oil wells and that mining western land is good because it makes land more productive when you “mix top soils”. See full extent of his ignorance on these & climate change at
https://www.eenews.net/stories/1060079255

Reason 104: Zinke is a hypocrite and does not listen to local input unless it is in Montana. A New York Times story documents how he has protected areas in Montana while ignored local input & done away with protections in other states. An article from Wyofile shows how he has ignored local input from Republican-dominated county commissions to strip State BLM of the authority to postpone leases to extractive industries in order to protect areas rife with wildlife & recreational areas. For documentation of these points, See https://www.wyofile.com/zinke-clips-state-blm-conservation-power-draws-wyoming-ire/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=weeklynewsletter
And https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/16/us/ryan-zinke-montana.html?emc=edit_th_180417&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=103654190417

Reason 103: Congress Rejects Zinke Budget. Zinke’s budget request for Interior made huge cuts in conservation but Congress ignored his idiotic request & funded 2.5 Billion more. But he & Repubs are planning to rescind this money. It shows again how he has no concern with conservation & is a terrible admin.—Congress including many Republicans reject his Energy Dominance Only preoccupation. See the full article on the cuts at https://www.hcn.org/articles/department-of-interior-what-will-zinke-do-with-the-extra-2.5-billion-in-his-budget?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 102. Zinke is violating the law by illegally extending the tenure of temporary directors such as Susan Combs who is Acting Secretary for Fish, Wildlife, and Parks.  I detailed in my Wildlife Politics book how she implemented a plan to avoid Federal regulations to preserve the threatened Sagebrush Lizard. Agreements with extractive industries & landowners were voluntary & the USFWS didn’t even have the right to view individual agreements to see if they were working! Combs like other Acting Directors does not have the credentials or support to win permanent status. This is just one more example of Zinke’s terrible appointments demonstrating he does not care about conservation at all. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/04/05/stories/1060078267 and https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2018/04/04/a-fierce-opponent-of-the-endangered-species-act-is-picked-to-oversee-interiors-wildlife-policy/?utm_term=.18ec8da25027

Reason 101: Zinke takes advice—from those who want to make a profit from public lands and destroy wilderness. His appointments to the Outdoor Recreation Committee include people from boat and snowmobile manufacturers and ATV dealers and those who have conflicts of interest as concessionaires and want to privatize camping and other park operations. It does not include anyone from the Outdoor Industry Asso. who conduct “nonomotorized activities” and who criticized scaling back Bears Ears. As usual, Zinke selects the worst possible advisors—those who oppose conservation and public lands. See https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/zinke-creates-new-outdoor-recreation-panel-made-up-entirely-of-industry-advisers/2018/03/26/04f3e960-2f9a-11e8-8688-e053ba58f1e4_story.html?utm_term=.e03a3ea966dc

Reason 100: Zinke’s only interest in wildlife is trophy hunting but data on hunting from the 2016 National Survey of Fishing, Hunting, and Wildlife PROVE that hunting continues to DECLINE with big decreases in hunting. Likewise, Excise tax revenues show a HUGE decline in revenues (33% to 37%) for pistols, firearms, and shells-cartridges. Indeed, the Wildlife Management Institute, a PRO-HUNTING organization states that “These numbers do not paint a very bright future for state fish and wildlife agency funding and the future of hunting and fishing.” These findings demonstrate that Zinke’s total focus and revenues derived from and his ignoring wildlife conservation and non-game species is disastrous. USFWS’s 2016 shows that the number of hunters continued a two-decade steady decline. By way of contrast, non-consumptive uses of wildlife continued a steady increase with 20% increase in those who watch nearby their homes and 3 percent increase in those who travel to view wildlife. The message is clear: We need to refocus the Interior Department’s and Zinke’s focus on trophy hunting—they are destroying wildlife conservation. New revenue sources not based on hunting need to be tapped. Zinke’s “leadership” is destroying conservation in the U.S. and is contrary to what MOST AMERICANS want from Interior and State wildlife agencies. The Excise data & Wildlife Management Institute data are available at: Wildlife Management Institute. https://wildlifemanagement.institute/outdoor-news-bulletin/february-2018/excise-tax-update  The USFWS 2016 survey is available at https://wsfrprograms.fws.gov/Subpages/NationalSurvey/nat_survey2016.pdf
​

Reason #99: Zinke does not seek balanced advice—he only listens to those he agrees with. For example, his hunting council is composed of celebrity hunting guides, representatives from rifle and bow manufacturers, and wealthy sportspeople who boast of bagging Big 5 trophies. “Most are high-profile members of Safari Club International and the National Rifle Association, groups that have sued the Fish and Wildlife Service to expand the list of countries from which trophy kills can be legally imported.” See Asso. Press story on this meeting at https://www.wsj.com/articles/APae53d56159b1468ca837db22538ce82e?mod=searchresults&page=1&pos=1

Reason 98: Zinke isn’t content with cutting budget for Interior’s conservation programs. He now is forcing BLM’s employees to wear insignia showing Oil Rigs & Cattle Ranching. He has no shame & cares not one whit for conservation or professionalism of his employees. He cares only about extractive industries & welfare ranchers (& trophy hunting). What a small, puny man he is! See https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/paloma/the-energy-202/2018/03/16/the-energy-202-interior-agency-gives-employees-vision-cards-depicting-oil-rigs/5aaaadcd30fb047655a06cbf/?utm_term=.0667a4f69f7d&wpisrc=nl_politics-pm&wpmm=1

Reason 97: Zinke is a doubletalker and coward. At hearing, he now says that there may be no drilling off Pacific—like Florida! He made a terrible decision and is unable to back it up—he deserves to be fired. At same time, he “virtually eliminated the Land & Conservation Fund” and cuts monuments. His defense—the monuments are still under “federal protectons”—well those are protections set up in previous Administrations that cared about conservation. This Administration & Republicans are eagerly looking to eliminate or weaken those protections such as  the Endangered Species Act. See account of his doubletalk & cowardice at https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2018/03/13/zinke-oil-and-gas-exploration-off-the-pacific-coast-might-not-happen/?utm_term=.50ecc7000f41

Reason 96: Zinke isn’t content to reduce monuments & park funding—he wants to litter areas surrounding them with mines & pumps. See https://www.denverpost.com/2018/03/09/great-sand-dunes-national-park-mineral-rights-auction/

Reason 95: Zinke will save parks by destroying public lands while cutting Interior Budget. Zinke’s Interior propose to provide funding for national parks infrastructure needs by taking money from energy developments on Federal lands and waters.  At the same time, he is proposing a 10% CUT to the Interior budget. So he brags about plan to “fund national parks” while cutting money from the budget of the agencies that run the parks & by destroying public lands and waters—that is the Zinke-Trump approach to conservation—fund parks by killing public land and conservation. See https://www.eenews.net/gw/2017/02/28 and
https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/03/07/stories/1060075699
​

Reason 94: Zinke is violating the law by having “Temporary” Directors to remain in charge for long periods of time. He has done this with 3 key positions: the directors of National Park Service, Bureau of Land Management, and Fish and Wildlife Service. See http://www.peer.org/news-releases/temporar-interior-directors-illegal.html

Reason 93: Zinke voids one of Trump’s rare humane actions—Trump referred to elephant trophy hunting as a “horror show” but Ryan Zinke only likes wildlife—elephants or any other species—that is available for trophies so his Interior Dept. has quietly allowed “permits” for trophies. See https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2018/03/06/trump-called-elephant-hunts-a-horror-show-his-administration-just-lifted-a-trophy-hunting-ban/?utm_term=.fa8914c7d7d9

Reason 92:   Zinke wants to kill unburdensome regs such as Obama’s Methane regulations for no good reason other than he wants zero minimum regulation of extractive industries. An article by Jonathan Thompson details the harm that would be done to the environment & conservation for the very minor costs  that regulation costs extractive industries. https://www.hcn.org/articles/methane-rules-in-danger?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason 91: Zinke treats Interior employees unfairly & unprofessionally. Many are resigning or retiring under protest such as 2 USGS professionals who refused to go along with his illegal use of information before it was released to the public. He has questioned the loyalty of his employees. He is planning on cutting 4000 employees—they are not needed anymore because Interior no longer cares about conservation and the environment—only energy dominance & turning over the land to extractive industries. See https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2018/02/21/two-scientists-have-left-the-interior-department-after-zinke-demanded-confidential-energy-data/?utm_term=.ab9249c13fcf&wpisrc=nl_green&wpmm=1

Reason 90: The Zinke-Trump budget will cut funds for protecting endangered species by 47 percent and USFWS overall budget by 19 percent or 300 million dollars—a budget that had already suffered huge cuts this year. Zinke does not care about his agency’s missions—his only concern is extractive industries & welfare ranchers. See http://www.biologicaldiversity.org/news/press_releases/2018/endangered-species-funding-02-13-2018.php

Reason 89:  The only interest Zinke has in conservation is for trophy hunters. His big “conservation announcement” in Utah was “to expand opportunities for big game hunting.” See official Department of Interior admission of this at https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/secretary-zinke-prioritizes-conservation-big-game-migration-corridors

Reason 88: Zinke appoints the worst people possible for Interior—those pushing for extractive industries with interests opposed to those of conservation. For example, Douglas Domenech Asst. Sec. for Insular Affairs is having his duties expanded. His qualifications? He lobbied for them, encouraged drilling on Virginia’s oceanfront, and authored the “moral case for fossil fuels”—an effort funded by Kochs & extractive industries. See https://departmentofinfluence.org/person/doug-domenech/

Reason 87: Zinke’s rush to turn over public lands to oil-gas-coal ignored science & follow NEPA rules & thus open to legal challenge. See New York Times article by Coral Davenport at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/31/climate/trump-zinke-environmental-rollback.html?em_pos=small&emc=edit_sc_20180205&nl=science-times&nl_art=11&nlid=10365419&ref=headline&te=
​
Reason 86: While Zinke shows no interest in the conservation goals of the Interior Department, he continues to show great interest in political fundraising that is heavily involved in direct-mail contributions. He is a political hack who is harming the environment as he pursues contributions from wealthy extractive industries. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/02/05/stories/1060072913

Reason 85: Zinke isn’t just for extractive industries—he wants to kill renewable energy sources, public lands, and conservation all at the same time in California “environmentally sensitive lands.” See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/02/01/stories/1060072665

Reason 84: Zinke has no ethics and no shame. He opened public lands to use of lead bullets—overturning previous regulations while not disclosing his ownership of shares in a company that produces the ammunition. See https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/zinke-proof-research-shares_us_5a60e1fae4b0b3f7fa12c397?vo4

Reason 83: Zinke lies and bad decisions don’t hold up when held up to public scrutiny—shows what an incompetent toady he is. His argument that “Florida is unique” is indefensible (except on political interpretation!) He has gotten away with destroying conservation due to lack of mass media attention but now his phoniness & incompetence have become clear. See https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2018/1/11/1731876/-Ryan-Zinke-says-Florida-is-obviously-unique-as-Trump-condemns-rest-of-coast-to-more-drilling

Reason 82: Zinke is an incompetent Administrator. This point is illustrated by his recent announcement that offshore drilling is out for Florida. Turns out he never discussed this was agency responsible for it & that decision has not been made—which is typical of his “spontaneous and confused decisions that have left policies vulnerable to legal challenge.” See https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/19/climate/offshore-drilling-florida.html?emc=edit_th_180120&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=10365419

Reason 81: Zinke is a threat to endangered species not only in the U.S. but worldwide. He is “stocking international wildlife panel” with big-game hunters, thus threatening attempts to save species like lions, elephants, and tigers. See E&E News at https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/01/18/stories/1060071325

 Reason 80: Zinke’s lack of concern for conservation is demonstrated by his failure to appoint a Director for the National Park Service—the first time this has happened since 1916. Since he only cares about “energy dominance,” this should not be surprising. See article in LA times at  http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-national-park-zinke-oil-gas-20180117-story.html

Reason 79: Zinke has totally ignored not only overwhelmingly majority of input from environmental-conservation groups but even that from the National Park Service Board that is supposed to provide guidance for his decisions—so much so that ALL of the members led by former Alaska Governor Tony Knowles resigned.  By way of contrast, he is filling Interior positions with former employees of extractive industries.  See https://www.mprnews.org/story/2018/01/17/npr-majority-of-national-park-service-board-resigns

Reason 78: Fish and Wildlife: Are they conservation agency or do they exist to foster “energy dominance?” Zinke’s USFWS is debating whether to remove goal of “net conservation gain” as goal of mitigation due to pressure from extractive industries. Actually, research shows that mitigation areas to compensate for loss of sensitive areas are often far inferior to the habitat being lost due to developments. Removal of this requirement is one more example of total abandonment of their conservation priority by this agency due to Zinke. See https://www.eenews.net/stories/1060070959

Reason 77: Zinke lies shamelessly and repeatedly. The New York Times reported that Zinke claimed that “there is no mine within Bears Ears” but actually there were “300 uranium mining claims inside the monument” and he brought alone Energy Fuels, the CANADIAN Uranium Mining company on his trip to Bears Ears while refusing to meet with Native American groups opposed to mining—but he claims that he claims he heeded “LOCAL voices” in his decision. See https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/13/climate/trump-uranium-bears-ears.html?_r=0

Reason 76: Zinke’s appointees such as Interior legal counsel Daniel Jorjani make blatantly illegal interpretations of laws and treaties to allow development by extractive industries such as in Twin Metals leases near Boundary Waters & incidental killing under Migratory Bird Act—hoping that Trump-appointed stooge judges will uphold. See http://www.timberjay.com/stories/twin-metals-decision-part-of-a-much-broader-initiative,13850

Reason 75: Zinke & his Bureau of Land Management deleted webpages concerning climate change, renewable energy, and the overall mission of the agency. He has undermined science and ignored the conservation mission of the agency.  His totally unbalanced actions to achieve “energy dominance” make a travesty of the Interior Dept.—it has become the Department of Extractive Industries & Welfare  Ranchers.  See https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-webpages-erased-and-obscured-under-trump/


Reason 74: Zinke ignores science in favor of politics in giving grants. E&E News reports that “The Interior Department will now funnel certain grants through a political screening intended to ensure the federal dollars "better align" with the administration's "priorities," according to a newly revealed memo. See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/01/09/stories/1060070507

Reason 73: Zinke names the least qualified, indeed the worst people possible, to head agencies under Interior. They oppose the missions of the agencies they are supposed to head and do everything they can to undermine them. For example, reports from E&E News say that Zinke will name a former park superintendent head of the National Park Service despite the fact that he helped wealthy people cut down trees.  See https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2018/01/05/stories/1060070251
 
Reason 72: Zinke’s Interior Department approved the building of a road through the Izembek National Wildlife Refuge that wildlife experts say will damage wildlife who depend on this habitat. The local officials & Japanese-owned local business say that the road is needed for access to medical care but the Federal government has already spent $50 million on providing\ such access. See Lisa Friedman, NewYorkTimes at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/07/climate/alaska-road-refuge.html?emc=edit_th_20180107&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=10365419

Reason 71: Zinke’s will remove protections for the Arctic. His draft proposal would calls for the removal of crucial Arctic protections and authorization of new leasing in this incredible landscape.  See https://www.worldwildlife.org/stories/trump-administration-to-roll-back-crucial-arctic-protections?utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=oceans

Reason 70: Zinke ignores science and revokes climate change and mitigation policies. He tells Interior to ignore climate change and revokes any need for mitigation of harm done by extractive industries.  See
http://www.hcn.org/articles/climate-change-interior-department-revokes-climate-change-and-mitigation-policies?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

​Reason 69: Zinke has opened virtually all offshore areas to drilling regardless of environmental and conservation threats.  Zinke’s pal, Thomas Pyle, President of American Energy Alliance, just said offshore areas:  “these are our lands.”  He is right. With Zinke & Trump in charge, all public lands and all offshore areas will belong to extractive industries. Until the public hears about these threats from the mass media & contacts their reps., these harmful actions will continue. See https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/04/climate/trump-offshore-drilling.html?emc=edit_th_20180105&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=10365419

Reason #68: Zinke will no longer enforce incidental  killing of migratory birds by industry—failing to enforce the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. See documentation at  http://www.audubon.org/news/the-white-house-turns-its-back-americas-birds

Reason 67: Zinke wants to mine on the Edge of Boundary Waters Canoe Area—an action previously blocked by Obama. He again shows is all out commitment to extractive industries—he could care less about conservation. He regards Interior as a Federal Mining Company. See http://www.wildlifepolitics.org/blog

Reason 66: Zinke’s Department ordered the National Academies study on the safety of offshore drilling to be stopped—another example of his all out reckless exploitation of natural resources with no concern for conservation & explicit rejection of science. See Gronewold, E&E News at https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/12/22/stories/1060069795

Reason 65: Zinke’s Interior Dept. is proposing to allow continued commercial fishing in the first U.S. Atlantic Ocean marine monument that researchers have called “an incredible biodiversity hotspot.”  Trump Administration Facing Battle Over New England Marine Monument. A no-fishing monument actually supports fishing because it allows fish “re-establishment zone” where populations are revived due to the lack of “human harvesting.”  See Hladky’s Hartford Courant article at http://www.courant.com/politics/hc-pol-coral-canyons-trump-threat-20171215-story.html

Reason 64: Zinke punishes Interior Department employees for making science-based statements about the harm that climate change will wreak on national parks.  Zinke doesn’t like science or freedom of speech when it contradicts Trump and his biases. See article by Timothy Cama at http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/364994-zinke-reprimanded-park-head-after-climate-tweets
​
Reason 63: Zinke is politicizing and slowing access to Freedom of Information Access (FOIA) requests. He has centralized all different agency FOIA requests into his central office under a political hack. See Washington Post article by Grandoni & Eilperin at https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2017/12/15/trump-environmental-officials-are-keeping-tight-rein-over-stampede-of-foia-requests/?utm_term=.8c18c378e566

Reason 62: Zinke devises false “local participation” in monument decision-making dominated by pro-development & few Native Americans who want monument. See Felicia Fonseca, “Tribes: Monument Co-Management Proposal Is Slap in the Face” at https://www.usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2017-12-11/tribes-decry-proposal-for-co-management-of-utah-monument
​
Reason 61: Zinke and House Republicans attack private company for expressing opposition to monument cutbacks.  This is another unethical action by Zinke.  See coverage of dispute with Pataogonia in article by Matthew Daly at http://www.denverpost.com/2017/12/11/ryan-zinke-gop-patagonia-feud/

Reason 60. Zinke ignored public comments and Native Americans concerning Bears Ears but Washington Post article documents how he paid close attention to uranium firm in decision to shrink Bears Ears. See Juliet Eilperin, “Uranium firm urged Trump officials to shrink Bears Ears National Monument” at https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/uranium-firm-urged-trump-officials-to-shrink-bears-ears-national-monument/2017/12/08/2eea39b6-dc31-11e7-b1a8-62589434a581_story.html?utm_term=.327ad11a3d0b
​
Reason #59: Zinke is systematically weakening key rules established to ensure that U.S. gets adequate revenues from extractive industries and gets input from Native Americans that would be affected by drilling and keep energy development away from sensitive areas. See article by Jonathan Thompson in High Country News at http://www.hcn.org/articles/department-of-interior-interiors-return-to-the-robber-baron-years?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email

Reason #58: Zinke is about to cut 1.6 billion from Interior Budget & reorganize it so that it is located near extractive industries & welfare ranchers—his plan is proposed by “advisers” working for Koch Brothers & extractive industries. See Chris D’Angelo. Republicans Turn To Industry For Advice On How To Reorganize Interior Department
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/interior-department-reorganization-hearing_us_5a295068e4b0fa798612887f

Reason #57: While Zinke cuts funding for conservation programs in Interior, he wastes money on expensive travel such as helicopters to ride his horse! Ryan Zinke “Spent $6,250 On A Helicopter So He Could Ride Horses With Mike Pence.” See article by Nick Visser at
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/ryan-zinke-helicopters_us_5a2a2337e4b069ec48ac3272?ncid=inblnkushpmg00000009
 
Reason 56: Zinke is preparing to cut back more monuments. He “supports cutting Nevada’s Gold Butte and Oregon’s Cascade-Siskiyou” and will be allowing motor vehicle traffic in Siskiyou and assuring grazing in New Mexico’s monuments. See https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/zinke-backs-shrinking-more-national-monuments-shifting-management-of-10-others/2017/12/05/e116344e-d9e5-11e7-b1a8-62589434a581_story.html?utm_term=.85da7d13a813
​
Reason 55. Zinke selects top Interior officials who oppose & will undermine the agency’s conservation purposes. For example, Zinke is considering Karen Budd-Falen to head the Bureau of Land Management (BLM). She has been a long-time critic of BLM favoring local government over Federal environmental regulations. She wants to cut back radically on monuments & supports legislation to do by Utah’s anti-conservation congressman, Rob Bishop. She criticizes national parks for being “single use” properties, talks enthusiastically about grazing, timber logging, and extractive industries use of BLM lands. She doesn’t mention conservation as a priority for the agency. In short, Zinke puts in power individuals like himself: they don’t care about the environment or conservation. See Jennifer Yachnin at http://www.wyofile.com/potential-blm-chief-vows-push-local-input-reduce-monuments/

54. Zinke is a big hypocrite—cuts monuments elsewhere but wants to add one in his home state of Montana. See https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/zinke-aims-to-shave-national-monuments-except-in-his-home-state_us_5a1b8315e4b0d4906cafab87

53. Even Republican supporters of Ryan Zinke now regret that he is head of Interior—they see that he lied when he said he was a “Teddy Roosevelt Republican.”  See E&E News at https://www.eenews.net/gw/2017/11/27

52. Zinke supported eliminating restrictions on the importation of elephant trophies & also loosed restrictions on importation of lion trophies. It shows once again that Zinke cares nothing about wildlife conservation other than supporting hunters seeking trophies.  See E&E News. https://www.eenews.net/gw/2017/11/21
​
51. Under Zinke’s (who cares about hunting & trophies above all), the USFWS reversed Obama policies and is now allowing imports of elephant and lion trophies despite the fact that these species are increasingly endangered & Zimbabwe is a dictatorial & terribly managed country.Interior Department to allow imports of elephant and lion trophies from Africa, reversing Obama policies https://blog.humanesociety.org/wayne/2017/11/interior-department-allow-imports-elephant-lion-trophies-africa-reversing-obama-policies.html

50. Zinke, the head of the Interior Department, has no comments about Bundy—the man who refuses to pay for his usage of public lands & who threatened BLM (Interior Department) personnel with guns when they tried to enforce Interior Department Regulations. Actually, it is a wonder why he hasn’t come out and supported & lauded Bundy—they are of the same mindset—the hell with conservation.  https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/11/07/stories/1060065865
​
49. Zinke’s Interior: Everything for Hunters, Nothing for Wildlife Conservation: According to E&E News, Zinke has expanded “hunting opportunities” at 9 wildlife refuges and opened another to sport fishing”—emphasizing that he does not care about the original purpose of refuges—to conserve wildlife—not kill it. https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/11/07/stories/1060065877
 
48. Zinke’s Terrible Personnel Management Policies: E&E News reports that Zinke has left important positions in the Interior Department vacant for an “unusually long time.” At the same time, he has hired former Navy Seal as his “recreation czar.”  This reinforces his view of his department as a military force & does not tolerate anyone who cares about priorities other than Zinke’s—i.e., making money for extractive corps. & public land welfare ranchers—except for unethical hunters. https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/11/07/stories/1060065875
 
47.  Zinke “repealed an Obama administration rule that ended a scam coal, oil and gas companies had long relied on to make deceitfully small royalty payments to the federal treasury.” As a result, “fossil-fuels companies can once again shortchange the public out of its royalties.” What’s more, Zinke raised entry fees to parks—the added fees are calculated to raise 70 million dollars for parks but the “calculated lost annual revenue from reopening the royalty loophole at $75 million.” What more can you say about him? He is a clear & present danger to public lands and conservation. See https://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/ryan-zinke-is-erasing-public-from-lands-hes-meant-to-guard/?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=article_left_1.1  
 
46. Zinke is planning to reverse ban on mining in watershed of Grand Canyon. See  http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/358311-trump-admin-to-reconsider-grand-canyon-uranium-mining-ban#.Wfpe3065vU0.twitter
 
45. Zinke had questionable ethics as a Member of Congress selling a vehicle at low cost violating campaign ethics rules and his poor ethical system has continued in office with his abuse of travel costs at the public’s great expense. See https://www.politico.com/story/2017/10/30/ryan-zinke-campaign-fec-complaint-244313
 
44. Zinke convinced Trump to shrink Bears Ears and Grand Staircase from 1.35 million acres down to 120,000 acres. The first big cutback in monuments by Zinke who claimed to be Teddy R. Republican—Roosevelt invented monuments. See http://www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2017/10/27/trump-tells-sen-orrin-hatch-hell-shrink-the-bears-ears-national-monument/

43. Zinke is going to eliminate Obama leasing reforms that keep energy development away from national parks and other environmentally sensitive areas. These reforms gave a voice to local and regional interests in how oil and gas is developed. For example, the reform closed 145,000 acres of federal lands near the Arches and Canyonlands national parks to future mineral leasing, capped well densities on projects in sensitive areas, and placed no surface occupancy restrictions on about 306,000 acres "that are highly valued for scenery and recreation.” See Scott Streater, Key Obama-era leasing reform to get the ax” at https://www.eenews.net/stories/1060064921
 
42: Zinke views environmental protections “burden” to “energy dominance. He wants to alter or remove End. Species Act, NEPA, Rules for offshore drilling & fracking. https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/department-interior-releases-energy-burdens-report
 
41. Zinke’s PAC has used unethical practices, focusing on getting donations from small donors who can ill afford these contributions and then spending most of the money on overhead. He continues to “closely associate with a PAC, ForthRight Strategy, whose former executive pleaded guilty to child pornography charges.” See Lefebre & Juliano, Politico, at http://www.politico.com/story/2017/10/24/zinke-fundraisers-republican-operatives-244094
 
40. Zinke refuses to say why he is cutting back monuments when overwhelming public support for them. See the YouTube Video where Zinke is interviewed about public monuments & can’t defend his recommendations to cut them. His position on monuments is especially notable because during his confirmation hearings he described himself as a “Teddy Roosevelt Republican”—Teddy Roosevelt is the president who pioneered the use of monuments for conservation. Zinke once again proves that he a liar and a hypocrite and his administration has no transparency. The video is at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5WeTDZMGZQ

39. Zinke’s Way: Everything for Hunters—Nothing for Wildlife Conservation. The USFWS is working on a plan to allow hunters to kill trumpeter swans—a species that has been protected. The purpose of this change is to protect hunters who (supposedly) mistakenly shoot the trumpeters & thought they were aiming at tundra swans—an unprotected species. This is simply another example of Zinke’s Interior Department & the Trump Admin. prioritizing unethical hunting over wildlife conservation goals. Similarly, USFWS is removing protections from wolves & grizzlies because they compete with hunters for elk and other “game species”—the only species that Zinke is interested in.  Zinke wants to broaden use of lead bullets and fishing gear to pander to unethical hunters-fishers who don’t want to spend a few more pennies to protect species from their harmful effects. The Trump Admin. is pushing a Sportsmen’s bill that will allow silencers because they are concerned about harming hearing of hunters as they kill animals. Zinke and the Trump Administration have sho[BR1] wn absolutely no interest in wildlife conservation—they will undoubtedly welcome the legislative moves to undermine (if not eliminate) the Endangered Species Act. Zinke, the Trump boys, and their friends like to kill wildlife—not preserve it. Article on Trumpeter Swans is available at: http://www.therepublic.com/2017/10/14/us-swan-hunting/
 
38. Zinke’s is working behind the scenes to build a controversial and long-contested road through the heart of Alaska’s Izembek National Wildlife Refuge, documents show. The Army Corps of Engineers has studied it & shown that alternatives to the road are superior. See article by Lorraine Chow at https://www.nationofchange.org/2017/10/17/groups-slam-zinkes-backroom-deals-build-road-alaskan-wildlife-refuge/
 
37. Zinke threatened Senator Lisa Murkowski over her vote on Obamacare. His implicit threat was to act against her priorities involving the Interior Department. This show how Zinke is willing to subvert any Interior Department issues to Trump political priorities. See https://www.adn.com/politics/2017/07/26/trump-administration-signals-that-murkowskis-health-care-vote-could-have-energy-repercussions-for-alaska/  In this case, Murkowski’s priorities are anti-conservation but the general principle is Zinke is willing to subvert Interior priorities for unrelated political concerns.

36. No ethical principles—Zinke minions approve harmful projects with conflicts of interest. Trump’s BLM removes a hurdle for controversial Mojave Desert Cadiz project which his Deputy Secretary will financially benefit from. Zinke has no problem with this ethical issue. The Obama Admin. and environmentalists opposed the project because of concerns that pumping enormous amounts of water out of the aquifer could deplete natural springs. The springs sustain habitat for rare wildlife in the desert such as tortoises and bighorn sheep.” See   http://www.hcn.org/articles/water-trumps-blm-bureau-of-land-management-clears-a-hurdle-for-controversial-cadiz-project?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
 
35.  Zinke Strikes Again: He has approved drilling near national monuments & parks—Oil, Coal, Gas Win, Conservation loses: Every day brings news of another Zinke action against the conservation goal of the Interior Dept. He will allow drilling near the Dinosaur National Monument and also approved oil and gas leases near Zion National Park, Capitol Reef National Park, Chaco Culture National Historical Park, Hovenweep National Monument and Fort Laramie National Historic Site. Zinke has shown no interest whatsoever in the conservation  goals of the Interior Dept. See story by Stephen Nash of New York Times at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/18/travel/drilling-near-dinosaur-monument.html?emc=edit_tnt_20171018&nlid=10365419&tntemail0=y

34. Zinke is pushing a road through an Alaskan Wildlife Refuge that studies by USFWS show will be harmful to wildlife. Moreover, he is doing it in a way to keep the planning of the road secret and thus unavailable for public scrutiny. This again shows Zinke’s priorities and characteristics—development over conservation and lack of transparency. See Washington Post; https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/interior-looks-at-behind-the-scenes-land-swap-to-allow-road-through-wilderness-refuge/2017/10/15/c6458380-aeb7-11e7-9e58-e6288544af98_story.html?utm_term=.98910da734cb

33. In just 2 years in Congress, Zinke received 350K from extractive industries. He is paying them back by turning public lands into mining-oil-gas moneymaking industries while destroying habitat & caring not at all for conservation aspects of Interior Department: https://wildernesswatch.org/

32. Zinke defends Confederate monuments—says they are necessary so that “we can learn from history”?? The monuments depict the defenders of slavery as heroes—Zinke is, like Trump, clueless and supporter of white supremacist. Source: http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/zinke-taking-down-confederate-statues-upset-native-indians?utm_content=buffera4129&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer

31. Zinke has opened public lands to ATVs and motor vehicles in areas such as Utah’s Recapture Canyon where they had been banned:  http://www.hcn.org/issues/49.7/latest-zinke-reopens-recapture-canyon-to-motor-vehicles?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
30. Zinke is all out for oil—no room for conservation or compromise for conservation or wildlife. In 2013, the Obama Admin. & Congress reached a COMPROMISE that opened large new areas for oil in exchange for protecting vital biodiverse lands.  No one sued over this compromise. But Zinke and his BLM are now putting up “every available tract” under the 2013 for lease to oil companies—this action is not based on industry demand—they are not even close to using the lands already available to them in Alaska. He wants to commit the area to oil drilling regardless. See Christopher Solomon. America’s Wildest Place is Open for Business. NYT.  Nov. 10, 2017. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/11/10/opinion/sunday/wildest-place-in-america.html?em_pos=large&emc=edit_ty_20171110&nl=opinion-today&nlid=10365419&ref=headline&te=1&_r=0

29. Zinke treats the Interior Dept. as his army unit—he accuses employees of disloyalty and has flags raised at the Dept. “headquarters in downtown Washington, Secretary Ryan Zinke has revived an arcane military ritual that no one can remember ever happening in the federal government.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/wheres-zinke-the-interior-secretarys-special-flag-offers-clues/2017/10/12/68672476-aeb2-11e7-9e58-e6288544af98_story.html?utm_term=.b663b91fa22f

28. Zinke lied about claims for energy production—he got “4 Pinocchios from Washington Post: http://missoulian.com/news/state-and-regional/zinke-earns-four-pinocchios-for-domestic-energy-production-claims/article_0a228cd7-b8a2-5812-9689-51e00f3cfb3a.html?utm_content=buffer2c912&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=LEEDCC

27 Zinke has abused travel wasting public funds on flights as reported by the media on September 29th.  See https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2017/09/28/59533ed8-a4b8-11e7-ade1-76d061d56efa_story.html?hpid=hp_hp-top-table-main_zinketravel-1105pm%3Ahomepage%2Fstory&utm_term=.35b74046bc9d

26 Zinke punishes professional employees for fighting climate change such as Joel Clement who was transferred from a job protecting Alaskan villages from rising seas to “auditing fossil fuel company leases as discussed in LA Times http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-trump-civil-servants-201709-story.html that allows Alaskans to kill wolf pups and bear cubs in dens in NATIONAL WILDLFIE REFUGES. Chicago Tribune: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/editorials/ct-edit-alaska-0313-jm-20170310-story.html

24 Zinke is opening BLM to more ORV use in sensitive areas which threatens archeological sites but is also very harmful to wildlife as has been proven by scientific research. High Country News: http://www.hcn.org/issues/49.7/latest-zinke-reopens-recapture-canyon-to-motor-vehicles?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=emailAnd pp. 295-335 of Todd Wilkinson, Science Under Siege.

23 Zinke has pushed policy changes that prioritize extractive industries and devalue conservation. His staff “filed a legal proposal to rescind the nation’s first safety regulation on hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. They are exploring a proposal to loosen safety rules on underwater drilling equipment put in place after the 2010 BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Zinke rolled back an Obama-era order to block coal mining on public lands and delayed carrying out a regulation controlling emissions of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas, from oil and gas wells.” New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/25/us/politics/interior-secretary-zinke-staff-conservation-regulations.html?emc=edit_th_20170726&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=10365419&_r=0

22 Zinke’s staff are dominated by extractive industry officials and lobbyists. An early count totaled 21 of his staff from extractive industries versus 3 from conservation-sports area. He hired Susan Combs of Texas to control the agency’s budget. Combs fought against USFWS efforts to preserve species. High Country News: http://www.hcn.org/articles/interiors-energy-priorities-undergird-sweeping-monuments-review?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email And High Country News:  http://www.hcn.org/articles/whos-up-for-trump-administration-positions-this-week?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
 
21 Zinke and Interior have denied endangered species protection to threatened species such as the Pacific Blue Fin Tuna. He toadies to the fishing industry. Ecowatch: https://www.ecowatch.com/bluefin-tuna-endangered-species-2470265690.html
20 Zinke gives private talks to groups that want to take over public lands for states and private interests such as ALEC-- American Legislative Exchange Council funded by the Koch Brothers and Exxon. By way of contrast, he gave little chance for input to conservationists in his review of monuments. High Country News: http://www.hcn.org/articles/department-of-the-interior-secretary-gives-closed-door-speech-to-alec?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
 
19 Zinke’s 2018 budget for the Bureau of Land Management would “shift B.L.M. funding for nonenergy programs to oil and gas production. With the bureau’s staff and resources already strained, the Trump budget would force the agency to short-circuit environmental reviews and impact assessments on energy development and curtail priorities important to rural communities that depend on the public lands, like fire prevention, rangeland improvement, conservation of fish and wildlife habitat, and recreation.” New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/28/opinion/trump-oil-public-lands.html?em_pos=small&emc=edit_ty_20170828&nl=opinion-today&nl_art=4&nlid=10365419&ref=headline&te=1&_r=0

18 Zinke has forced the Interior Department to speed oil & gas leases on public lands that would “short circuit” environmental reviews of these leases—the leases run for at least 10 years & often much longer. New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/28/opinion/trump-oil-public-lands.html?em_pos=small&emc=edit_ty_20170828&nl=opinion-today&nl_art=4&nlid=10365419&ref=headline&te=1&_r=0

17 Even sportsmen, the one “conservation group” that Zinke pays any attention to, find his policies wrong including the shrinking of monuments and inattention to conservation. High Country News: http://www.hcn.org/articles/public-lands-as-sportsmen-watch-zinke-disillusionment-replaces-hope?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
 
16 Zinke and Trump appointed National Rifle Association official (lobbyist) to the US National Park Foundation board—she wants to get rid of regulations that hinder hunting and wants to allow baiting and killing of cubs and other unethical hunting practices.  http://www.independent.co.uk/news/nra-us-national-park-foundation-donald-trump-susan-lapierre-womans-leadership-forum-a7928791.html

15 Zinke supports opening the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to extractive industries—again demonstrating his top priority is “energy dominance” and cares nothing for conservation. New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/16/climate/trump-arctic-refuge-drilling.html?mcubz=3&_r=0

14 Zinke is totally focused on hunting and game species—he cares nothing for non-game animals and the vast majority of the public who like to watch wildlife instead of hunt it. But these non-game watchers spend far more money and support communities near conservation areas than hunters. EE News: https://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/stories/1060061129/most_read
 
13 Zinke misled Trump and the public on the monuments that have previously been cut. In most of these cases, the land remained protected such as by the National  Park Service. Again, demonstrates that nothing Zinke says can be trusted. EE News: https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/09/21/stories/1060061363
 
12 Zinke supports Department of Interior’s top lawyer Ryan Nelson who wants to make it hard or impossible for conservationists to delay logging and other activities that harm wildlife. EE News: https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/09/21/stories/1060061353
 
11 Zinke supports “aggressive forest thinning” to deal with wildfires despite the fact that it is climate change and weather that cause the fires and that ecologists have shown that this this thinning has bad consequences for ecosystems and the fires have good effects for wildlife and elk hunters.  High Country News: http://www.hcn.org/articles/dc-dispatch-zinkes-fire-memo-calls-for-aggressive-thinning-of-western-forests?utm_source=wcn1&utm_medium=email
 
10 Zinke wants to privatize campsites on public lands—which is guaranteed to increase prices for campers & turn over key decisions to those who care about profit first: The New Mexican http://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/idea-to-privatize-campsites-has-opponents-worried-prices-could-skyrocket/article_6b27e3e2-e9cf-56c9-bf13-2ca02cbb71a1.html
 
9 Zinke is giving more “flexibility” to welfare ranchers on Bureau of Land Management (BLM) in how cows graze public lands. There is a mountain of evidence such as that described in George Wuerthner’s Welfare Ranching (book) and Lynn Jacobs Waste of the West (book) that ranching is harmful to the lands and wasteful subsidy of the welfare ranchers who abuse the land. The BLM’s own survey shows their lands are in terrible shape though they try to deny that it is due to omnipresent welfare rancher grazing. EE News: https://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/2017/09/22/stories/1060061495

8 Zinke doesn’t understand or doesn’t listen to science—for example, he focuses on sage grouse populations instead of habitat conservation and proposes using captive breeding to support sage grouse—both approaches are discredited by science. Audubon: http://www.audubon.org/magazine/fall-2017/zinkes-new-conservation-plans-will-hurt-not-help
7 Zinke has accused Interior employees of disloyalty—showing that he does not understand the purpose of the department he heads. His “loyalty” comments have been roundly condemned by public employees & ethicists. His concept of loyalty is based on loyalty to the chain of command—Trump and Zinke—while employees should be loyal to the assistance Interior provides to the U.S.—not Trump, Zinke, and extractive industries. EE News: https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/09/26/stories/1060061733
 
6 Zinke supports so-called “Sportsmen’s Heritage Bill” that protects use of lead bullets including in wildlife refuges. Lead bullets have been proven to be harmful to species such as the Condor demonstrating and are inexpensive—surveys show that most hunters support the use of non-lead bullets. Again that Zinke cares more about unethical hunters & the NRA than conservation: New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/27/opinion/editorials/nra-guns-california-trump.html?em_pos=small&emc=edit_ty_20170927&nl=opinion-today&nl_art=3&nlid=10365419&ref=headline&te=1And http://nmpoliticalreport.com/209535/lead-zinke-ban-public-lands-en/

5 Zinke’s report on monuments contained several factual errors concerning them exposed by Senator Heinrich of New Mexico showing that Zinke is ignorant, a liar, and incompetent:  https://medium.com/westwise/senator-calls-out-multiple-factual-errors-in-national-monuments-report-to-donald-trump-9c462ac1251b
 
4 In hearings for his job, he claimed he was a “Teddy Roosevelt Republican” but TR was the first president used the Antiquities Act to expand monuments while Zinke is pushing major cutbacks to monuments. These cutbacks despite conclusive survey evidence that western state citizens support monuments & don’t want to cut them—only small but powerful extractive industry and welfare ranchers favor cutbacks: E&E News: https://www.eenews.net/greenwire/2017/09/27/stories/1060061887
 
3 Instead of fighting for conservation & national parks, he pushes for “energy dominance” as if he were Sec. of Energy. Our national parks are overwhelmed with visitors & need more support but the Trump-Zinke budget proposes a 13 percent budget cut! New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/27/us/national-parks-overcrowding.html?emc=edit_th_20170928&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=10365419&_r=0
 
2 He is scrapping the Sage Grouse compromise plan that took years to negotiate between the Obama Admin. & western states—he is devoted first and foremost to “new mineral leasing, grazing and other commercial activities across the quirky bird’s Western habitat.” He went ahead without consulting western governors of Wyoming & Colorado who helped forge the compromise.  Audubon Society http://www.audubon.org/magazine/fall-2017/zinkes-new-conservation-plans-will-hurt-not-help And  New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/28/climate/trump-sage-grouse.html?emc=edit_tnt_20170928&nlid=10365419&tntemail0=yAnd Wyofile: http://www.wyofile.com/western-governors-fret-zinke-ponders-review-grouse-plans/1

1 The major reason why Zinke won easy confirmation was based on his opposition to takeover of Federal public lands by states but his record shows no concern for conservation. “He has a 4 percent lifetime score from the League of Conservation Voters, and oil and gas companies have donated nearly $350,000 to his campaigns. He is a strong supporter of coal — “we are not going to power our nation on pixie dust and hope,” he told a local crowd in 2014 — and has pushed to end Mr. Obama’s moratorium on new coal leases.” The only wildlife Zinke cares about are game or fish that he consumes. The only public lands users he cares about are extractive industries, welfare ranchers, and hunters. He care nothing for non-game animals or people who want to enjoy wildlife without killing it.  New York York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/01/us/for-interior-montanan-with-deep-roots-and-inconsistent-record.html?emc=edit_th_20170302&nl=todaysheadlines&nlid=10365419&_r=0
 

 [BR1]